← Back to Collatio XI: De secunda visione tractatio quarta, quae est secunda de speciositate fidei et agit de speculatione Dei trini

Coll. 11

Collationes in Hexaëmeron · Collatio XI: De secunda visione tractatio quarta, quae est secunda de speciositate fidei et agit de speculatione Dei trini

Contents
  1. COLLATION XI.
  2. On the second vision: the fourth treatment, which is the second on the comeliness of faith and treats of the speculation of God as three.
  3. Summarium
Textus Latinus
p. 379
The numbered footnotes below correspond to markers in both the Latin body above and the English translation; Quaracchi restart their numbering on every printed page, so the labels are qualified by page.

COLLATIO XI.

De secunda visione tractatio quarta, quae est secunda de speciositate fidei et agit de speculatione Dei trini.

Summarium

Introductio. Repetuntur dicta de altitudine et firmitate fidei; nunc de speciositate, quae est in duodecim speculationibus, 1. — Pars I. De speculo primo, quod est intellectuale, ex nominibus Dei intellectualibus; hoc est speculum Augustini, 2-4. — Sed nos cum Ruth colligamus spicas post messores. Duplex est speculum Trinitatis, intellectuale et magis materiale; quoad primum quatuor rationes in Deo pro Trinitate speculanda, 5. — Primo, ex triplici perfectione: originis, ordinis, indivisionis, 6-8. — Secundo, ex perfecta productione, quae est sex modorum, 9. — Obiectio solvitur, 10. — Tertio, ex productiva diffusione triplici: actualissima, integerrima, ultimata, 11. — Quarto, ex diffusiva dilectione, quae est triplex, 12. — Pars II. De speculo secundo, congregato ex parvis: Verbum naturaliter habet rationem exprimendi, et duodecim generationes creaturarum hoc exprimunt, tribus modis: per diffusionem, expressionem, propagationem, 13. — Prima via has generationes applicandi ad aeternam generationem; primo quoad diffusionem quadruplicem, 14. 15. — Secundo, quoad expressionem quadruplicem, 16. 17. — Tertio, quoad propagationem quadruplicem, 18. 19. — De his duodecim modis in communi, 20. 21. — Secunda via easdem applicandi; primo quoad diffusionem, 22. — Secundo, quoad expressionem, 23. 24. — Tertio, quoad propagationem, 25.

1. Nos vero omnes, revelata facie gloriam Domini speculantes6 etc. Dictum est de secunda visione, scilicet intelligentiae per fidem elevatae, quae intelligitur per caelum vel firmamentum, quod est altum, fir-p. 380mum et speciosum. Dictum est de altitudine et firmitate; nunc de speciositate dicendum est. — Dictum est enim: Suspice caelum et numera stellas, si potes1; et in Apocalypsi de civitate, quae habebat duodecim portas, et portae ex singulis margaritis. Duodecim ergo sunt speculationes, quae oriuntur ex fide; et prima est de Deo, quod sit primum esse, de qua dictum est, quia primum nomen Dei est qui sum2. Nunc dicendum est de secunda, scilicet quod Deus est trinus et unus.

2. Hoc speculum format Augustinus decimo quinto de Trinitate3, capitulo quarto4, ubi ponit duodecim conditiones sive nomina, quae de Deo dicuntur, ut sit aeternus, immortalis, incorruptibilis, immutabilis, vivus, sapiens, potens, speciosus, iustus, bonus, beatus, spiritus. Ex istis colligit Trinitatem.

3. Sapiens5 enim est per sapientiam, et beatus per beatitudinem, et sic de aliis; et non aliud est ipse et sua sapientia, sed est ipsa sapientia. Est ergo ibi mens, notitia, amor; et haec tria sunt unum, quia ipsa mens intelligendo se gignit notitiam sui, et ex mente et notitia procedit amor: ergo est ibi Trinitas in unitate substantiae. — Sic Pater est mens, Filius notitia, Spiritus sanctus amor sive nexus; et haec est appropriatio, quae fit ad Patrem, Filium et Spiritum sanctum6.

4. Haec duodecim redigit7 ad tria, scilicet ad aeternitatem, sapientiam, beatitudinem, et haec tria ad unum, scilicet ad sapientiam, quia in sapientia est aeternitas et beatitudo. Et in sapientia est notitia8 sui, et ex notitia amor; et ideo dicit Anselmus in Monologio9. Ex hoc enim, quod summus Spiritus se intelligit, Filius p. 381generatur, Spiritus sanctus spiratur. Hoc est speculum Augustini. Sed nos cum Ruth1 colligamus spicas post messores secundum doctores nostros.

5. Est autem duplex speculum Trinitatis: unum intellectuale, quod facit intelligere nomina dicta de Deo intellectualia; secundum est magis materiale, quod fit per nomina transsumtiva. — Prima speculatio est, quod intelligentia per fidem elevata dicit, Deum esse trinum et unum, propter quatuor, quae sunt in divino esse, scilicet propter conditionem perfectionis, propter conditionem perfectae productionis, productivae diffusionis, diffusivae dilectionis; et unum sequitur ex altero.

6. Est enim ibi summa perfectio, ex qua fit, quod primum principium habet perfectionem originis, ordinis, indivisionis. — Est autem origo originans perfectior quam non originans, et perfectior est origo originans originantem quam originans non originantem: ergo si ibi est perfecta origo, necesse est, esse Patrem producentem Filium originantem et Spiritum sanctum originatum.

7. Item, a parte ordinis sic: ubi est perfectus ordo, ibi est ratio principii, medii et ultimi; alioquin ordo esset diminutus: ergo in divinis erit iste ordo perfectus. Et est ordo originis, non dignitatis nec temporis nec naturae2.

8. Item, a parte indivisionis. Est enim unitas consubstantialitatis, totalitatis sive plenitudinis, conformitatis, individuationis, voluntatis, inseparabilitatis3. Unitas autem consubstantialitatis deficit in principiatis, quia non habent eandem substantiam cum principio, ut patet in forma sine materia4. — Item, unitas totalitatis sive plenitudinis in principiatis deficit, quia non est ex se nec simplex. — Item, unitas in universalibus deficit, scilicet conformitatis, quia numeratur cum alia; licet enim sit in pluribus, numeratur tamen in illis. — Item, unitas in individuis deficit, quia cum materia numeratur forma5. — Item, unitas voluntatis deficit, quia non ita coniunguntur animi, quin separari possint per discordiam. — Item, unitas inseparabilitatis deficit in naturis, quia non est tam fortis unio formae, quin possit per artificium separari. — Haec6 autem in Deo ponenda.

9. Item, in primo esse est ratio perfectae productionis. Est autem productio similis et dissimilis, aequalis et inaequalis, consubstantialis et essentialiter differentis. — De necessitate, si est productio dissimilis, praeintelligitur productio similis; quod sic patet: simile habet se ad dissimile, sicut idem ad diversum, sicut unum ad multa; sed de necessitate idem praecedit diversum, et unum multa7: ergo productio similis productionem dissimilis. Sed creatura producitur a primo esse et est dissimilis: ergo de necessitate producitur simile, quod est Deus. — Item, secundum Boethium8 inaequalitates oriuntur ab aequalitate: si ergo producitur a Deo quod est inaequale, scilicet creatura, necessario praecedit productio aequalis, quod est Deus. — Item, si producitur a Deo essentialiter differens, necessario ante producitur substantialiter idem, quia ante extrinsecum est intrinsecum, ut patet: quia verbum dicentis extrinsecum praecedit mentis conceptus ut aliquid intrinsecum: ergo similiter a substantia aeterna non manat differens, nisi producatur substantialiter idem: ergo in Deo prius est productio similis, aequalis, consubstantialis quam dissimilis, inaequalis, essentialiter differentis.

10. Sed quid? dices, nunquid intelligendo, primum esse unum esse suppositum, ut gentiles, adhuc intelligunt substantiam, virtutem et operationem? Ergo, non intellecta trinitate vel emanatione, est intelligere productionem. Respondeo: intellectus duplex est: perfectus et plenus et plene resolvens; et tali intellectu non est intelligere sic; intelligere autem semiplene potest intellectus defectivus sic, quod resolvat in plura, quae in Deo sunt unum, aliter non9.

11. Item, tertia ratio speculi est, quia in Deo est ratio productivae diffusionis sic. Illud esse est summe bonum, ergo summe diffundit se10 triplici diffusione: actualissima, integerrima, ultimata sive ultimatissima. Quia actualissima, semper est, semper fuit, semper erit; semper generat, semper generavit, semper generabit. Hoc non potest habere creatura, quod semper sit, semper fuerit et semper futura sit: ergo necesse est, ut emanet aeternus11. — Item, integerrima non est haec diffusio in creatura, quia Deus non dat totum decorem exemplaritatis creaturae, immo non dat nisi generando Filium, qui dicere potest: Omnia, quae habet Pater, mea

p. 382sunt1; hoc non dicit aliqua creatura. — Item, haec diffusio est ultimata, ut det producens, quidquid potest; creatura autem recipere non potest, quidquid Deus dare potest. Unde sicut punctus ad lineam nihil addit, nec etiam mille millia punctorum2; sic bonitas creaturae bonitati Creatoris nihil addit, quia finitum infinito nihil addit. Ergo necesse est, ut haec diffusio secundum totum posse sit in aliquo, quo maius cogitari non potest; omni autem creatura aliquid maius cogitari potest, et etiam ipsa creatura maior se cogitari potest. Sed in Filio est productio, sicut in Patre. Si ergo Patre nihil maius cogitari potest: ergo nec Filio. Si Pater etiam ultimata diffusione non se diffunderet, perfectus non esset.

12. Quarta diffusio est per rationem dilectionis. Necessario enim oportet, quod ubi beatitudo est, ibi summa sit dilectio, et per consequens dilectio in summo. Est autem dilectio reflexa, connexiva, caritativa. Connexiva dilectio perfectior est, qua alterum diligo, quam reflexa, qua me diligo; caritativa autem perfectior ceteris est, quae habet dilectum et condilectum: ergo haec est in divinis. Hac ergo dilectione Pater diligit Filium, et est infinitus ardor3. — Item, est ibi dilectio gratuita, debita, permixta. — Item, est ibi dilectio pura, plena, perfecta, ut effluens et effluxa in Filio, ut refluxa in Spiritu sancto. Ex istis rationibus omnibus fit illud speculum nobile.

13. Est autem aliud speculum, congregatum ex parvis. Unde nota, quod licet tota Trinitas sit lumen intelligendi, Verbum tamen naturaliter habet rationem exprimendi4. Omnis autem creatura clamat generationem aeternam, et hanc exprimunt et repraesentant duodecim generationes, quas reperimus in creaturis. Est enim primus modus generationis per diffusionem, secundus per expressionem, tertius per propagationem.

14. Per diffusionem, ut splendoris a luce, ut caloris ab igne, ut fluminis a fonte, ut imbris a nube plena sive rorida. — In prima diffusione deficit aequalitas, quia splendor non aequatur luci. — In secunda deficit intimitas, quia calor non est intimus igni sive ut informanti, sive ut originanti; est enim accidens5. — In tertia deficit simultas, quia fons diffundit se per partes, non totus insimul. — In quarta deficit integritas, quia non tota pluvia excutitur a nube, immo per guttas. — Iungas has quatuor conditiones ad unam diffusionem, quae sit splendoris habentis aequalitatem, caloris habentis intimitatem et substantialitatem, rivuli sive fontis habentis simultatem, imbris habentis integritatem: et sic habes vestigium generationis aeternae.

15. Unde Filius aliquando comparatur splendori, ad Hebraeos primo6: Qui cum sit splendor gloriae etc.; aliquando flammae, ut in rubo Moysi, ubi fuit expressa persona Filii; aliquando fluvio vel fonti, ut in Genesi: Fons ascendebat de terra, et fluvius egrediebatur de loco voluptatis; aliquando imbri, ut in Isaia: Quomodo descendit imber et nix de caelo et illic ultra non revertitur, sed inebriat terram etc., et sequitur: Sic erit verbum meum, quod egreditur de ore meo, scilicet de corde Patris.

16. Secundus modus est per modum expressionis: ut speciei ab obiecto, ut imaginis a sigillo, ut sermonis a loquente, ut conceptus sive cogitatus a mente. — Et in his est defectus. In prima deficit rei veritas, quia species in oculo vel in anima non est veritas rei7. — In secunda deficit simplicitas, quia imago sive figura non est in puncto vel in simplici, sed partes habet. — In tertia deficit stabilitas, quia sermo transit et non manet. — In quarta deficit substantialitas, quia conceptus mentis non est substantia, vel hypostasis. — Auferas hos defectus et pone expressionem, quae sit ut speciei ab obiecto habentis veritatem, ut imaginis a sigillo habentis simplicitatem, ut sermonis a loquente habentis stabilitatem, ut conceptus a mente habentis substantialitatem: et tunc habebis alteram partem speculi.

17. De primo, Psalmus8: Eructavit cor meum verbum bonum, et sequitur: Speciosus forma prae filiis hominum. — De secundo, Sapientiae septimo: Candor est lucis aeternae et speculum sine macula et imago bonitatis illius; et Apostolus: Qui est imago invisibilis Dei. — De tertio, Iob: Semel loquitur Deus et idipsum non repetit. Unde pone in Filio, quod semper sit et non deficit nec vertitur. — Quarto pone substantialitatem. Conceptus enim mentis aeternae est hypostasis, et iste conceptus mentalis est nobilissimus, perfectissimus. Unde in Proverbiis9: Nondum erant abyssi, et ego iam concepta eram. Aliquando ergo vocatur filius, species, imago, verbum manens in aeternum, conceptus vero non inhaerens, sed substantialis et hypostasis. Sic ergo habemus aliam partem speculi.

p. 38318. Tertia generatio est per modum propagationis, et hoc quadrupliciter: ut germinis a semine, ut arboris a radice, ut prolis conceptae a ventre vel utero materno, ut filii a patre principiante. — In prima generatione deficit formositas, quia in semine est forma confusa et occulta; sed non sic filius. — In secunda deficit conformitas, licet enim sit una radix, tamen differt in forma a ramis, licet unam arborem faciant. — In tertia deficit actualitas, quia mater est principium, etsi aliquo modo activum prolis, potissime tamen passivum. — In quarta deficit coaevitas.

19. Aufer ergo hos defectus et pone primo formositatem. Unde Isaias1: Erit germen Domini in magnificentia et gloria, et fructus terrae sublimis. — Secundo pone conformitatem; sic Filius est conformis Patri, ut sit lignum vitae in medio paradisi; unde in Proverbiis: Lignum vitae est his qui apprehenderint eam. — Tertio pone actualitatem. Unde in Psalmo2: Tecum principium in die virtutis tuae in splendoribus Sanctorum; ex utero ante luciferum genui te. Ex utero, dicit, ubi est ratio fovendi in sinu Patris, a quo non recessit. — Quarto pone coaevitatem. Unde in Psalmo: Ego hodie genui te; hoc est in aeternitate, sive in meo hodie aeterno.

20. Has duodecim conditiones aggrega, et habebis speculum ad contuendum exemplar divinum sive Verbum, quod omnia repraesentat: ut splendor procedens a luce cum perfectione aequalitatis, et sic de aliis. — Et per has conditiones solvuntur omnia argumenta Arii, per quae arguit a generationibus imperfectis3.

21. De his duodecim generationibus dicitur in Genesi4: Vidi per somnium quasi solem et lunam et stellas undecim adorare me. Iste est ille Ioseph pulcherrimus, quem adorant omnia; et clamant temporalia per lunam, spiritualia per solem, et undecim stellae. Generationes creaturarum sunt secundum undecim conditiones, deficiente duodecima, quae est in generatione Filii Dei; ideo ponuntur hic undecim stellae in numero deficiente a duodenario, qui est numerus excrescens5, quia omnia respectu illius generationis habent defectum et inclinant se ad generationem Verbi; omnia enim indicant generationem Verbi. — Unde quando videtur splendor a luce, transferenda est mens ad considerandam generationem aeternam; et sic de aliis. — Et ibi est magna delectatio, de qua in Psalmo6: Delectasti me, Domine, in factura tua; et in operibus manuum tuarum exsultabo. Dicit ergo: Nos autem, revelata facie gloriam Domini speculantes.

22. Alio modo sic, et est magis proprie. Est generatio per diffusionem ut splendoris vel luminis a luce; et ibi est coaevitas, deficit tamen aequalitas, quia splendor non aequatur luci. — Item, est diffusio, ut ignis ab igne, et ibi est aequalitas, ut patet, quando una candela accenditur ab alia, quod tantum est lumen in una, sicut in alia, et quotquot accendantur; deficit tamen consubstantialitas. — Item, est diffusio rivuli a fonte, et hic est consubstantialitas vel intimitas, quia eadem aqua, quae est in fonte, est in rivulo7; sed deficit nobilitas ortus, quia de imo, et per quosdam meatus et colationem de aqua salsa fit dulcis. — Item, est diffusio imbris a nube, et ibi est nobilitas ortus, quia habet virtutes caeli, per quas infundit imbrem nubes; deficit tamen formae decor, quia videtur nubes caelum obscurare et deturpare. — Iunge quod nobilitatis est, ut coaevitatem et aequalitatem, consubstantialitatem et formae decorem; et habes unam partem speculi.

23. Item, est generatio per expressionem ut speciei ab obiecto; et hic est formae decor, qui deficiebat in generatione imbris. Et hoc est mirabile, quomodo talis species generatur; quia non de materia aëris, quia, cum non dicat essentiam, sed modum essendi, sufficit, ut habeat principium originativum, medium inter principium materiale et principium effectivum. Unde Deus dedit virtutem hanc cuilibet rei, ut gignat similitudinem suam et ex naturali fecunditate. Unde secundum quod obiectum gignit similitudinem suam, sic repraesentat generationem aeternam; secundum quod intentio animae eam oculo unit, sic repraesentat incarnationem Verbi8. — Haec generatio speciei deficit, quia non est p. 384ibi formae fixio, sed vario modo habet generari, ut patet in speculis vario modo ordinatis; et diversimode habet repraesentare, prope, vel longe.

24. Item, est generatio per expressionem ut figurae a sigillo, et hic est formae fixio, quod deficit in praecedenti, deficit tamen vitae vigor. — Item, est generatio sermonis a dicente, ubi est vitae vigor, quia sermo quandam vim vitae secum habet; ut patet, quod duobus dicentibus eandem veritatem, unus melius alio exprimit et imprimit. Unde Hieronymus1: « Habet nescio quid latentis energiae vivae vocis actus » etc. Unde verba Christi, non est dubium, quin, prolata et audita de ore eius, maioris virtutis et potestatis erant quam scripta. Hic tamen deficit vitae mansio, quia sermo transit. — Item, est generatio conceptus a mente; et ibi est vitae mansio, quia omnis cogitatus in memoria manet; sed hic deficit fecunditatis substantialis virtus, quia ille cogitatus non est substantialis virtus. — Haec quatuor iungantur, scilicet formae decor, formae fixio, vitae vigor, vitae mansio, et habes secundam partem speculi.

25. Item, est generatio per propagationem ut germinis a semine; et hic est virtus substantialis, in qua ultimum deficit, scilicet deficit vitae robur. — Item, est generatio ut surculi a radice; et hic est vitae robur, sed deficit vivax sensus; non enim sentit vel producens productum, vel productum suam originem. — Item, est generatio ut fetus a ventre vel utero; et hic est vivax sensus, sed deficit virtus activa, quia venter est quasi receptaculum potius quam activum. — Item, est generatio ut filii a patre; et ibi sunt omnes dictae conditiones praeter unam, scilicet lucis, quae est coaevitas, quae ponenda est in generatione Filii Dei; et ab ista ultima generatione, scilicet filii a patre, denominatur generatio aeterna. Et hoc ratificavit Christus, cum dixit2: Ite, docete omnes gentes, baptizantes eos in nomine Patris et Filii et Spiritus sancti; non dixit: in nomine lucis et splendoris.

Hae sunt undecim stellae adorantes Ioseph, Filium pulcherrimum, scilicet undecim conditiones nobiles iam dictae, sed duodecima, scilicet coaevitas, est in Filio Dei.

---

English Translation

COLLATION XI.

On the second vision: the fourth treatment, which is the second on the comeliness of faith and treats of the speculation of God as three.

Summarium

Introduction. What was said of the height and the firmness of faith is recalled; now of its comeliness, which lies in the twelve speculations, 1. — Part I. On the first mirror, which is intellectual, drawn from the intellectual names of God; this is Augustine's mirror, 2–4. — But let us with Ruth glean the ears after the reapers. The mirror of the Trinity is twofold, intellectual and more material; as to the first, four grounds in God for contemplating the Trinity, 5. — First, from the threefold perfection: of origin, of order, of indivision, 6–8. — Second, from perfect production, which is of six modes, 9. — An objection is resolved, 10. — Third, from productive diffusion, which is threefold: most actual, most entire, most ultimate, 11. — Fourth, from diffusive love, which is threefold, 12. — Part II. On the second mirror, gathered out of small things: the Word naturally has the character of expressing, and twelve generations of creatures express this, in three modes: by diffusion, by expression, by propagation, 13. — The first way of applying these generations to the eternal generation; first as to the fourfold diffusion, 14. 15. — Second, as to the fourfold expression, 16. 17. — Third, as to the fourfold propagation, 18. 19. — On these twelve modes in general, 20. 21. — The second way of applying the same; first as to diffusion, 22. — Second, as to expression, 23. 24. — Third, as to propagation, 25.

1. But we all, beholding the glory of the Lord with open face6 etc. It has been said of the second vision, namely that of the understanding raised by faith, which is understood by heaven or the firmament, which is lofty, firm and comely. It has been said of its height and its firmness; now its comeliness must be spoken of. — For it was said: Look up to heaven and number the stars, if thou canst1; and in the Apocalypse, of the city which had twelve gates, and the gates of single pearls. There are, therefore, twelve speculations which arise out of faith; and the first is of God, that he is first being, of which it has been said, since the first name of God is he who is2. Now the second must be spoken of, namely that God is three and one.

2. This mirror Augustine frames in the fifteenth book On the Trinity3, chapter four4, where he sets down twelve conditions or names which are said of God: that he is eternal, immortal, incorruptible, immutable, living, wise, powerful, comely, just, good, blessed, spirit. From these he gathers the Trinity.

3. For he is wise5 by wisdom, and blessed by blessedness, and so of the rest; and he himself and his wisdom are not other, but he is wisdom itself. There is therefore there mind, knowledge, love; and these three are one, because the mind itself, by understanding itself, begets knowledge of itself, and from mind and knowledge proceeds love: therefore there is there a Trinity in unity of substance. — Thus the Father is mind, the Son knowledge, the Holy Spirit love or bond; and this is the appropriation which is made to Father, Son and Holy Spirit6.

4. These twelve he reduces7 to three, namely to eternity, wisdom, blessedness, and these three to one, namely to wisdom, because in wisdom are eternity and blessedness. And in wisdom is knowledge8 of itself, and from knowledge love; and therefore Anselm says in the Monologion9. For from this, that the highest Spirit understands himself, the Son is generated, the Holy Spirit is breathed. This is Augustine's mirror. But let us with Ruth1 glean the ears after the reapers, following our own doctors.

5. Now the mirror of the Trinity is twofold: one intellectual, which makes us understand the names said of God that are intellectual; the second is more material, which is made through transsumptive names. — The first speculation is that the understanding raised by faith says that God is three and one, on account of four things which are in the divine being, namely on account of the condition of perfection, on account of the condition of perfect production, of productive diffusion, of diffusive love; and one follows from the other.

6. For there is there the highest perfection, from which it comes that the first principle has the perfection of origin, of order, of indivision. — Now an origin that originates is more perfect than one that does not originate, and an origin that originates one which itself originates is more perfect than one that originates what does not originate: therefore if there is there a perfect origin, it is necessary that there be a Father producing a Son who originates, and a Holy Spirit originated.

7. Likewise, on the side of order, thus: where there is perfect order, there is the character of beginning, of middle, and of last; otherwise the order would be diminished: therefore in the divine persons this order will be perfect. And it is an order of origin, not of dignity nor of time nor of nature2.

8. Likewise, on the side of indivision. For there is a unity of consubstantiality, of totality or fullness, of conformity, of individuation, of will, of inseparability3. Now the unity of consubstantiality fails in things that are principiated, because they have not the same substance as their principle, as appears in form without matter4. — Likewise, the unity of totality or fullness fails in things principiated, because such a thing is not from itself nor simple. — Likewise, unity fails in universals, namely that of conformity, because it is numbered along with another; for although it be in many, it is nevertheless numbered in them. — Likewise, unity fails in individuals, because form is numbered along with matter5. — Likewise, the unity of will fails, because minds are not so joined but that they can be separated through discord. — Likewise, the unity of inseparability fails in natures, because the union of form is not so strong but that it can be separated by art. — These things6, however, are to be posited in God.

9. Likewise, in the first being there is the character of perfect production. Now production is of the like and of the unlike, of the equal and of the unequal, of the consubstantial and of what differs essentially. — Of necessity, if there is production of the unlike, production of the like is understood beforehand; which appears thus: the like stands to the unlike as the same to the diverse, as one to many; but of necessity the same precedes the diverse, and one precedes many7: therefore the production of the like precedes the production of the unlike. But a creature is produced by the first being and is unlike: therefore of necessity a like is produced, which is God. — Likewise, according to Boethius8, inequalities arise from equality: if therefore there is produced by God what is unequal, namely a creature, necessarily there precedes a production of the equal, which is God. — Likewise, if there is produced by God what essentially differs, necessarily there is produced beforehand what is substantially the same, because the intrinsic is before the extrinsic, as appears: because the word of the speaker, which is extrinsic, is preceded by the concept of the mind as something intrinsic: therefore likewise from the eternal substance there does not flow what differs, unless there be produced what is substantially the same: therefore in God the production of the like, the equal, the consubstantial is prior to that of the unlike, the unequal, the essentially differing.

10. But what then? you will say: does not one who understands the first being to be one supposit, as the gentiles did, nevertheless understand substance, power and operation? Therefore, without the trinity or emanation being understood, it is possible to understand production. I respond: the intellect is twofold: one perfect and full and fully resolving; and by such an intellect it is not possible to understand thus; but a defective intellect can understand half-fully in such a way that it resolves into several things what in God are one — otherwise not9.

11. Likewise, the third ground of the mirror is that in God there is the character of productive diffusion, thus. That being is most highly good, therefore it diffuses itself most highly10 by a threefold diffusion: most actual, most entire, most ultimate or ultimatemost. Because most actual, it always is, always was, always will be; it always generates, always generated, always will generate. A creature cannot have this, that it always is, always was, and always will be: therefore it is necessary that what emanates be eternal11. — Likewise, this diffusion is not most entire in a creature, because God does not give the whole beauty of his exemplarity to a creature, nay he does not give it save by generating the Son, who can say: All things whatsoever the Father hath are mine1; this no creature says. — Likewise, this diffusion is most ultimate, so that the producer gives whatever he can; but a creature cannot receive whatever God can give. Hence, as a point adds nothing to a line, nor even a thousand thousands of points2, so the goodness of a creature adds nothing to the goodness of the Creator, because the finite adds nothing to the infinite. Therefore it is necessary that this diffusion according to the whole power be in something than which a greater cannot be thought; but than every creature something greater can be thought, and even the creature itself can be thought greater than itself. But in the Son there is production, as in the Father. If therefore nothing greater than the Father can be thought, then neither than the Son. If the Father too did not diffuse himself by an ultimate diffusion, he would not be perfect.

12. The fourth diffusion is by the character of love. For necessarily it behoves that where beatitude is, there be the highest love, and consequently love in the highest. Now love is reflexive, connective, charitable. Connective love, by which I love another, is more perfect than reflexive, by which I love myself; but charitable love is more perfect than the rest, which has a beloved and a co-beloved: therefore this is in the divine persons. By this love, then, the Father loves the Son, and it is an infinite ardour3. — Likewise, there is there love gratuitous, due, mixed. — Likewise, there is there love pure, full, perfect, as flowing forth and flowed forth in the Son, as flowing back in the Holy Spirit. Out of all these grounds that noble mirror is made.

13. But there is another mirror, gathered out of small things. Whence note that although the whole Trinity is the light of understanding, the Word nevertheless naturally has the character of expressing4. Now every creature cries out the eternal generation, and this the twelve generations which we find in creatures express and represent. For the first mode of generation is by diffusion, the second by expression, the third by propagation.

14. By diffusion, as of brightness from light, as of heat from fire, as of a stream from a spring, as of rain from a full or dewy cloud. — In the first diffusion equality fails, because brightness is not equalled to light. — In the second inwardness fails, because heat is not inward to fire either as informing it or as originating it; for it is an accident5. — In the third simultaneity fails, because a spring diffuses itself by parts, not the whole at once. — In the fourth integrity fails, because not the whole rain is shaken out of the cloud, but by drops. — Join these four conditions into one diffusion, which shall be that of brightness having equality, of heat having inwardness and substantiality, of a stream or spring having simultaneity, of rain having integrity: and so you have a vestige of the eternal generation.

15. Hence the Son is sometimes compared to brightness, to the Hebrews, chapter one6: Who being the brightness of his glory etc.; sometimes to a flame, as in the bush of Moses, where the person of the Son was expressed; sometimes to a river or spring, as in Genesis: A spring rose out of the earth, and a river went out of the place of pleasure; sometimes to rain, as in Isaiah: As the rain and the snow come down from heaven and return no more thither, but soak the earth etc., and there follows: So shall my word be, which shall go forth from my mouth, that is, from the heart of the Father.

16. The second mode is by way of expression: as of a species from an object, as of an image from a seal, as of speech from one speaking, as of a concept or thought from the mind. — And in these there is a defect. In the first the truth of the thing fails, because the species in the eye or in the soul is not the truth of the thing7. — In the second simplicity fails, because an image or figure is not in a point or in what is simple, but has parts. — In the third stability fails, because speech passes and does not remain. — In the fourth substantiality fails, because a concept of the mind is not a substance, or hypostasis. — Take away these defects and posit an expression which shall be as of a species from an object having truth, as of an image from a seal having simplicity, as of speech from a speaker having stability, as of a concept from a mind having substantiality: and then you will have the other part of the mirror.

17. Of the first, the Psalm8: My heart hath uttered a good word, and there follows: Beautiful above the sons of men. — Of the second, Wisdom, chapter seven: She is the brightness of eternal light, and the unspotted mirror and the image of his goodness; and the Apostle: Who is the image of the invisible God. — Of the third, Job: God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing. Hence posit in the Son that he always is and does not fail nor is changed. — Fourth, posit substantiality. For the concept of the eternal mind is a hypostasis, and that mental concept is most noble, most perfect. Hence in Proverbs9: The depths were not as yet, and I was already conceived. Sometimes, therefore, he is called son, species, image, a word remaining unto eternity, but a concept not inhering, but substantial and a hypostasis. So then we have the other part of the mirror.

18. The third generation is by way of propagation, and this in four ways: as of a shoot from seed, as of a tree from a root, as of offspring conceived from the mother's womb, as of a son from a father as his beginning. — In the first generation shapeliness fails, because in the seed the form is confused and hidden; but not so the son. — In the second conformity fails, for although there be one root, it nevertheless differs in form from the branches, though they make one tree. — In the third actuality fails, because the mother is a principle, even if in some way active of the offspring, yet chiefly passive. — In the fourth coaevity fails.

19. Take away, therefore, these defects, and posit first shapeliness. Hence Isaiah1: The bud of the Lord shall be in magnificence and glory, and the fruit of the earth shall be high. — Second, posit conformity; thus the Son is conformed to the Father, so that he is the tree of life in the midst of paradise; whence in Proverbs: She is a tree of life to them that lay hold on her. — Third, posit actuality. Hence in the Psalm2: With thee is the principality in the day of thy strength, in the brightness of the saints; from the womb before the day star I begot thee. From the womb, he says, where there is the character of being cherished in the bosom of the Father, from whom he did not depart. — Fourth, posit coaevity. Hence in the Psalm: This day have I begotten thee; that is, in eternity, or in my eternal today.

20. Gather these twelve conditions, and you will have a mirror for gazing upon the divine exemplar or Word, which represents all things: as brightness proceeding from light with the perfection of equality, and so of the rest. — And by these conditions all the arguments of Arius are resolved, by which he argued from imperfect generations3.

21. Of these twelve generations it is said in Genesis4: I saw in a dream as it were the sun and the moon and eleven stars worshipping me. This is that most beautiful Joseph, whom all things adore; and temporal things cry out by the moon, spiritual things by the sun, and the eleven stars. The generations of creatures are according to eleven conditions, the twelfth failing, which is in the generation of the Son of God; and therefore eleven stars are set here, in a number falling short of the twelve, which is an abundant number5, because all things in respect of that generation have a defect and incline themselves to the generation of the Word; for all things indicate the generation of the Word. — Hence, when brightness is seen from light, the mind is to be carried over to considering the eternal generation; and so of the rest. — And there is great delight there, of which in the Psalm6: Thou hast given me, O Lord, a delight in thy doings; and in the works of thy hands I shall rejoice. He says, therefore: But we, beholding the glory of the Lord with open face.

22. In another way thus, and it is more proper. There is a generation by diffusion, as of brightness or light from light; and there is coaevity there, yet equality fails, because brightness is not equalled to light. — Likewise, there is a diffusion as of fire from fire, and there equality is present, as appears when one candle is lit from another, that there is as much light in the one as in the other, and however many be lit; yet consubstantiality fails. — Likewise, there is the diffusion of a stream from a spring, and here there is consubstantiality or inwardness, because the same water which is in the spring is in the stream7; but nobility of origin fails, because it is from below, and through certain channels and a straining it is made sweet out of salt water. — Likewise, there is the diffusion of rain from a cloud, and there is nobility of origin, because it has the powers of the heavens, through which the cloud pours out the rain; yet beauty of form fails, because the cloud is seen to darken and disfigure the heaven. — Join what is of nobility, namely coaevity and equality, consubstantiality and beauty of form; and you have one part of the mirror.

23. Likewise, there is a generation by expression, as of a species from an object; and here there is beauty of form, which was failing in the generation of rain. And this is wonderful, how such a species is generated; because it is not from the matter of the air, since, as it states not an essence but a mode of being, it suffices that it have an originative principle, midway between a material principle and an effective principle. Hence God gave this power to each thing, that it should beget its own likeness, and that out of natural fecundity. Hence, according as the object begets its own likeness, so it represents the eternal generation; according as the intention of the soul unites it to the eye, so it represents the incarnation of the Word8. — This generation of a species fails, because there is not there a fixity of form, but it comes to be generated in varying ways, as appears in mirrors arranged in varying ways; and it represents diversely, near or far.

24. Likewise, there is a generation by expression as of a figure from a seal, and here there is fixity of form, which fails in the preceding, yet vigour of life fails. — Likewise, there is the generation of speech from one speaking, where there is vigour of life, because speech has with it a certain force of life; as appears in that, when two men speak the same truth, one expresses and impresses it better than the other. Hence Jerome1: « The living voice has I know not what of hidden energy in its act » etc. Hence the words of Christ, there is no doubt, when uttered and heard from his mouth, were of greater power and might than when written. Here, however, the abiding of life fails, because speech passes. — Likewise, there is the generation of a concept from the mind; and there is the abiding of life there, because every thought remains in the memory; but here the substantial power of fecundity fails, because that thought is not a substantial power. — Let these four be joined, namely beauty of form, fixity of form, vigour of life, the abiding of life, and you have the second part of the mirror.

25. Likewise, there is a generation by propagation, as of a shoot from seed; and here there is substantial power, in which the last thing fails, namely the strength of life fails. — Likewise, there is a generation as of a slip from a root; and here there is the strength of life, but living sense fails; for neither does the producer feel the produced, nor the produced its own origin. — Likewise, there is a generation as of offspring from the womb or belly; and here there is living sense, but active power fails, because the womb is as it were a receptacle rather than something active. — Likewise, there is a generation as of a son from a father; and there are all the said conditions except one, namely that of light, which is coaevity, which is to be posited in the generation of the Son of God; and from this last generation, namely of a son from a father, the eternal generation takes its name. And Christ ratified this when he said2: Go, teach ye all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit; he did not say: in the name of light and of brightness.

These are the eleven stars worshipping Joseph, the most beautiful Son — namely the eleven noble conditions already spoken of; but the twelfth, namely coaevity, is in the Son of God.

---

Apparatus Criticus
  1. 6
    Epist. II. Cor. 3, 18.
    Second epistle to the Corinthians 3:18.
  2. 1
    Gen. 15, 5. — Seq. locus est Apoc. 21, 10; tertius Apoc. 21, 21. (portae ex singulis margaritis). Cfr. collat. praeced.
    Gen. 15:5. — The following passage is Apoc. 21:10; the third, Apoc. 21:21 (the gates of single pearls). Cf. the preceding collation.
  3. 2
    Exod. 3, 14. Cfr. collat. praeced.
    Exod. 3:14. Cf. the preceding collation.
  4. 3
    Libr. XV. de Trin. c. 8. n. 14: « Nos autem revelata facie gloriam Domini speculantes [II. Cor. 3, 18.]. Speculantes dixit per speculum videntes, non de specula prospicientes... Ibi quippe speculum, ubi apparent imagines rerum, a specula, de cuius altitudine longius aliquid intuemur, etiam sono verbi distat omnino, satisque apparet, Apostolum a speculo, non a specula dixisse gloriam Domini speculantes ». Ibid. c. 9. n. 16. exponit verba I. Cor. 13, 12: Videmus nunc per speculum in aenigmate, dicens: Proinde quantum mihi videtur, sicut nomine speculi imaginem voluit intelligi; ita nomine aenigmatis quamvis similitudinem, tamen obscuram et ad perspiciendum difficilem.
    Book XV On the Trinity, c. 8, n. 14: « But we, beholding the glory of the Lord with open face [2 Cor. 3:18]. He said beholding (speculantes) meaning seeing through a mirror (speculum), not looking out from a watchtower (specula)… For a mirror, where images of things appear, differs altogether even in the sound of the word from a watchtower, from whose height we look out at something farther off; and it appears well enough that the Apostle said beholding the glory of the Lord from speculum, not from specula. » Ibid. c. 9, n. 16, he expounds the words of 1 Cor. 13:12, We see now through a glass in a dark manner, saying: Accordingly, so far as it seems to me, as by the name of mirror he wished an image to be understood, so by the name of enigma he wished a likeness, but one obscure and difficult to see through.
  5. 4
    Num. 6. Cfr. supra pag. 214, nota 4.
    Number 6. Cf. above, page 214, note 4.
  6. 5
    Sap. 8, 2.
    Wisd. 8:2.
  7. 6
    Cfr. Breviloq. p. I. c. 6.
    Cf. Breviloquium, part I, chapter 6.
  8. 7
    Scilicet Augustinus, XV. de Trin. c. 5. seq. n. 7-10, ubi praenotata duodecim attributa redigit ad tria, scil. aeternitatem, sapientiam et beatitudinem; deinde haec tria reducit ad unum, scil. sapientiam. Cfr. Breviloq. p. I. c. 2. circa finem.
    Namely Augustine, XV On the Trinity c. 5 f., nn. 7–10, where he reduces the twelve attributes noted above to three, namely eternity, wisdom and blessedness; then he leads these three back to one, namely wisdom. Cf. Breviloquium, part I, chapter 2, near the end.
  9. 8
    Cfr. August., loc. cit., c. 7. n. 11.
    Cf. Augustine, at the place cited, c. 7, n. 11.
  10. 9
    Cap. 29. seqq.
    Chapter 29 ff.
  11. 1
    Ruth 2, 7: Et rogavit, ut spicas colligeret remanentes, sequens messorum vestigia.
    Ruth 2:7: And she asked leave to glean the ears of corn that remained, following the steps of the reapers.
  12. 2
    Collat. 8. n. 12. Cfr. collat. 1. n. 12. et 14.
    Collation 8, n. 12. Cf. collation 1, nn. 12 and 14.
  13. 3
    Cfr. supra pag. 63, nota 5.
    Cf. above, page 63, note 5.
  14. 4
    Ut forma sine materia. — Inferius retinuimus quia non est ex se nec simplex, quod A B C E G omittunt; D in plurimis, sicut patet.
    As form without matter. — Lower down we have retained because it is not from itself nor simple, which A B C E G omit; D reads in very many, as appears.
  15. 5
    Cfr. collat. 9. n. 24.
    Cf. collation 9, n. 24.
  16. 6
    Scilicet indivisio.
    Namely indivision.
  17. 7
    Aristot., II. de Caelo et mundo, text. 22. (c. 4.): Prius natura in unoquoque genere est unum multis, et simplex composito. Cfr. supra pag. 12, nota 9. Libr. X. Metaph. text. 10. (IX. c. 3.) idem ait: Item, unius quidem est... idem, simile et aequale; multitudinis vero diversum, dissimile et inaequale est.
    Aristotle, II On the Heaven and the World, text 22 (c. 4): In each genus the one is by nature prior to the many, and the simple to the composite. Cf. above, page 12, note 9. Book X of the Metaphysics, text 10 (IX, c. 3), says the same: Likewise, to unity belong… the same, the like and the equal; but to multitude, the diverse, the unlike and the unequal.
  18. 8
    Libr. I. de Arithmetica, c. 32.
    Book I On Arithmetic, chapter 32.
  19. 9
    Cfr. I. Sent. d. 28. dub. 1.
    Cf. I Sent. d. 28, dubium 1.
  20. 10
    Vide supra pag. 60, nota 7.
    See above, page 60, note 7.
  21. 11
    Cfr. I. Sent. d. 9. q. 4. et 5.
    Cf. I Sent. d. 9, qq. 4 and 5.
  22. 1
    Ioan. 16, 15: Omnia, quaecumque habet etc.
    John 16:15: All things whatsoever he hath etc.
  23. 2
    Cfr. Aristot., I. de Generat. et corrupt. text. 8. (c. 2.), III. Metaph. text. 16. (II. c. 4. in fine) et de Lineis insecabilibus (circa finem). Vide etiam III. Sent. d. 9. dub. 3.
    Cf. Aristotle, I On Generation and Corruption, text 8 (c. 2), III Metaphysics, text 16 (II, c. 4, at the end), and On Indivisible Lines (near the end). See also III Sent. d. 9, dubium 3.
  24. 3
    Cfr. I. Sent. d. 2. q. 4. De seq. propositione vide Richard. a S. Vict.; cfr. supra pag. 314, nota 1.
    Cf. I Sent. d. 2, q. 4. On the following proposition see Richard of St. Victor; cf. above, page 314, note 1.
  25. 4
    Cfr. I. Sent. d. 6. q. 3. et d. 27. p. II. q. 1. seqq. — Pro naturaliter B D E principaliter.
    Cf. I Sent. d. 6, q. 3, and d. 27, p. II, q. 1 ff. — For naturaliter B, D and E read principaliter.
  26. 5
    Aristot., de Praedicam. c. de Quali, docet, calorem esse qualitatem. Cfr. Averroes, in VIII. Metaph. text. 5.
    Aristotle, in the Categories, the chapter On Quality, teaches that heat is a quality. Cf. Averroes, on VIII Metaphysics, text 5.
  27. 6
    Vers. 3. — Subinde respicitur Exod. 3, 2. (cfr. supra collat. 3. n. 13.); allegatur Gen. 2, 6: Fons ascendebat e terra; et v. 10: Et fluvius etc.; Isai. 55, 10. (Vulgata illuc pro illic) et 11.
    Verse 3. — Thereupon Exod. 3:2 is referred to (cf. above, collation 3, n. 13); Gen. 2:6 is adduced: A spring rose out of the earth; and v. 10: And a river etc.; Isa. 55:10 (the Vulgate has illuc for illic) and 11.
  28. 7
    Aristot., III. de Anima, text. 38. (c. 8.): Necesse est autem, aut ipsas [res] aut formas esse; ipsas igitur non; non enim lapis in anima est, sed forma.
    Aristotle, III On the Soul, text 38 (c. 8): It is necessary that either the things themselves or their forms be [in the soul]; not the things themselves, then; for it is not the stone that is in the soul, but its form.
  29. 8
    Psalm. 44, 2. et 3. — Seq. locus est Sap. 7, 26, ubi Vulgata post sine macula addit Dei maiestatis; tertius Col. 1, 15; quartus Iob 33, 14: Semel loquitur Deus et secundo idipsum etc.
    Ps. 44:2 and 3. — The following passage is Wisd. 7:26, where the Vulgate after sine macula adds Dei maiestatis; the third, Col. 1:15; the fourth, Job 33:14: God speaketh once, and repeateth not the selfsame thing a second time etc.
  30. 9
    Cap. 8, 24. — Inferius respicitur Isai. 40, 8: Verbum autem Domini nostri manet in aeternum.
    Chapter 8:24. — Lower down Isa. 40:8 is referred to: But the word of our Lord endureth for ever.
  31. 1
    Cap. 4, 2. — Seq. locus est Gen. 2, 9; tertius Prov. 3, 18.
    Chapter 4:2. — The following passage is Gen. 2:9; the third, Prov. 3:18.
  32. 2
    Psalm. 109, 3. — Subinde respicitur Ioan. 1, 18: « Unigenitus Filius, qui est in sinu Patris »; et allegatur Ps. 2, 7, quem locum August., Enarrat. in Ps. 2, ita exponit: Hodie, quia praesentiam significat, atque in aeternitate nec praeteritum... nec futurum... sed praesens tantum, quia quidquid aeternum est, semper est; divinitus accipitur secundum id dictum Ego hodie genui te, quo sempiternam generationem virtutis et sapientiae Dei, qui est unigenitus Filius, fides sincerissima et catholica praedicat.
    Ps. 109:3. — Thereupon John 1:18 is referred to: « The only-begotten Son, who is in the bosom of the Father »; and Ps. 2:7 is adduced, which passage Augustine, Enarration on Psalm 2, expounds thus: Today, because it signifies presence, and in eternity there is neither past… nor future… but only present, since whatever is eternal always is; it is taken in a divine sense according to that saying This day have I begotten thee, by which the most sincere and catholic faith proclaims the everlasting generation of the power and wisdom of God, who is the only-begotten Son.
  33. 3
    Cfr. I. Sent. d. 13. dub. 8, ubi secundum Arium duodecim modi generationis proponuntur.
    Cf. I Sent. d. 13, dubium 8, where twelve modes of generation are set out according to Arius.
  34. 4
    Cap. 37, 9.
    Chapter 37:9.
  35. 5
    Partes siquidem duodenarii (habet enim quinque partes: duodecimam, sextam, quartam, tertiam, dimidiam) simul ductae non duodecim, sed sexdecim sunt. Cfr. August., IV. de Gen. ad lit. c. 2. n. 4, ex quo quaedam attulimus tom. IV. pag. 972, nota 3. Vide etiam tom. III. pag. 536, nota 1.
    For the parts of twelve (it has five parts: a twelfth, a sixth, a fourth, a third, a half), taken together, are not twelve but sixteen. Cf. Augustine, IV On Genesis to the Letter, c. 2, n. 4, from which we have adduced some things in vol. IV, page 972, note 3. See also vol. III, page 536, note 1.
  36. 6
    Psalm. 91, 5. — Seq. locus est II. Cor. 3, 18: Nos vero omnes, revelata etc. (cfr. initium huius collat.).
    Ps. 91:5. — The following passage is 2 Cor. 3:18: But we all, with open face etc. (cf. the beginning of this collation).
  37. 7
    Aristot., I. Topic. c. 6. (c. 5.): Omnis aqua omni aquae eadem specie dicitur, eo quod habeat quandam similitudinem; ab eodem autem fonte aqua, quae eadem dicitur, nullo alio differt, quam eo quod vehementior sit similitudo. — De fluviorum et fontium generatione agit Aristot., I. Meteor. Sum. 4. c. 1. (c. 13.); ibid. II. Sum. 1. c. 3, insinuat modum, quo aqua salsa fiat dulcis, scil. quod mediante percolatione quod terrenum est et ex admixtione salsedinem facit secernatur.
    Aristotle, I Topics, c. 6 (c. 5): All water is said to be the same in species as all other water, in that it has a certain likeness; but water from the same spring, which is called the same, differs in nothing else than that the likeness is stronger. — Aristotle treats of the generation of rivers and springs in I Meteorology, Summa 4, c. 1 (c. 13); ibid. II, Summa 1, c. 3, he suggests the way in which salt water becomes sweet, namely that by a straining what is earthy, and by its admixture makes the saltness, is separated out.
  38. 8
    Cfr. Itinerarium mentis in Deum, c. 2. n. 4. et 7; de Reductione artium ad theolog. n. 8.
    Cf. the Itinerarium mentis in Deum, c. 2, nn. 4 and 7; On the Reduction of the Arts to Theology, n. 8.
  39. 1
    Epist. 53. (alias 103.) ad Paulinum, n. 2: Habet nescio quid latentis energiae viva vox, et in aures discipuli de auctoris ore transfusa fortius sonat. (Haec epist. ut prologus in Biblia exhibetur; ideoque G ponit: Hieronymus in prologo Bibliae). Cfr. eius Comment. in Gal. 4, 20. Vide tom. II. pag. 266, nota 5.
    Epistle 53 (elsewhere 103) to Paulinus, n. 2: The living voice has I know not what of hidden energy, and poured into the ears of a disciple from the author's own mouth it sounds more strongly. (This epistle is presented as a prologue in the Bible; and therefore G reads: Jerome in the prologue of the Bible.) Cf. his Commentary on Galatians 4:20. See vol. II, page 266, note 5.
  40. 2
    Matth. 28, 19: Euntes ergo docete etc.
    Matt. 28:19: Going therefore, teach ye etc.
Cite this

St. Bonaventure, Collationes in Hexaëmeron, Coll. 11, in Opera Omnia (Quaracchi, 1891), tom. V, pp. 379–384.

English translation: Wroot Press, Bonaventure Opera Omnia Translation Project, bonaventure.wrootpress.com/hexaemeron/c11. Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0.

Authorities cited here

Anselm of Canterbury, Monologion · Aristotle, Categoriae (Praedicamenta), De anima, De caelo, De generatione et corruptione, Metaphysica (2), Meteorologica, Topica · Augustine of Hippo, De Genesi ad litteram, De Trinitate (3), Enarrationes in Psalmos · Averroes (Ibn Rushd), Commentarium in Metaphysicam · Boethius, De institutione arithmetica · Jerome, Epistolae