Dist. 2, Part 1, Divisio Textus
Book II: On the Creation of Things · Distinction 2
COMMENTARIUS IN DISTINCTIONEM II.
Pars I.
Quando creati sunt Angeli et de mensura durationis eorum.
De angelica itaque natura etc.
DIVISIO TEXTUS.
Supra egit Magister de rerum productione in generali. In hac parte agit de productione rerum in speciali. Et quoniam triplex est differentia creaturae, scilicet spiritualis et corporalis et composita ex utraque, ideo haec pars habet tres. In prima agit de conditione spiritualis creaturae. In secunda de conditione corporalis creaturae, infra distinctione duodecima: Haec de angelicae naturae etc. In tertia de conditione naturae ex utrisque compositae, scilicet humanae, infra distinctione decima sexta: His excursis, quae supra de homine. Prima pars habet duas. In prima determinat, quales facti sunt Angeli ex prima conditione. In secunda determinat, quales facti sunt ex aversione et conversione, infra distinctione quinta: Post haec consideratio adducit etc. Prima pars habet duas. In prima determinat, quando et ubi creati sunt Angeli. In secunda vero, quales creati sunt, infra distinctione tertia: Ecce ostensum est, ubi Angeli etc.
Prima pars habet duas. Primo enim determinat, quando Angeli creati fuerunt; in secunda, ubi, infra distinctione eadem: Iam ostensum est etc. Prima pars habet quatuor particulas. In prima praemittit prooemium, in quo aperit suam intentionem. In secunda vero movet1 dubitationem circa durationem sive initium vel mensuram angelicae conditionis, ibi: Quaedam auctoritates videntur. In tertia determinat veritatem et confirmat, ibi: Videtur itaque, hoc esse tenendum. Quarto vero et ultimo veritatem praedeterminatam et probatam concludit, et auctoritatem in oppositum determinat, ibi: Simul ergo cum tempore etc.
TRACTATIO QUAESTIONUM.
Ad intelligentiam huius partis, in qua quaeritur de mensura conditionis angelicae naturae, duo principaliter quaeruntur.
Primo de mensura eius in se.
Secundo per comparationem ad mensuram esse corporalis naturae.
Circa primum tria quaeruntur.
Primo, utrum spiritualia habeant mensuram propriam.
Secundo, utrum habeant mensuram unicam.
Tertio, utrum habeant mensuram simplicem aut compositam, sive stantem vel successivam.
---
COMMENTARY ON DISTINCTION 2.
Part I.
When the angels were created, and on the measure of their duration.
"As to the angelic nature," etc.
DIVISION OF THE TEXT.
Above, the Master treated of the production of things in general. In this part he treats of the production of things in particular. And since the difference of creatures is threefold — namely spiritual, corporeal, and composite of both — therefore this part has three [subdivisions]. In the first he treats of the condition of the spiritual creature. In the second, of the condition of the corporeal creature, below at distinction 12: "These things concerning the angelic nature," etc. In the third, of the condition of the nature composed of both — namely the human — below at distinction 16: "These things having been surveyed, which [were said] above concerning man." The first part has two [subdivisions]. In the first he determines of what kind the angels were made from [their] first condition. In the second he determines of what kind they became by the turning-away and the turning-toward [God], below at distinction 5: "After these things consideration leads on," etc. The first part has two [subdivisions]. In the first he determines when and where the angels were created. In the second, of what kind they were created, below at distinction 3: "Behold, it has been shown where the angels [are]," etc.
The first part has two [subdivisions]. For first he determines when the angels were created; in the second, where, below at the same distinction: "It has already been shown," etc. The first part has four particles. In the first he sets forth a proem, in which he opens his intention. In the second he raises1 a doubt concerning the duration — or the beginning, or the measure — of the angelic condition, at: "Certain authorities seem [to suggest]." In the third he determines the truth and confirms [it], at: "It seems, therefore, that this is to be held." In the fourth and last he concludes the truth thus predetermined and proved, and determines the authority [adduced] to the contrary, at: "Together therefore with time," etc.
TREATMENT OF THE QUESTIONS.
For the understanding of this part, in which it is asked concerning the measure of the condition of the angelic nature, two things are principally asked.
First, concerning its measure in itself.
Second, by comparison to the measure of the being of corporeal nature.
Concerning the first, three things are asked.
First, whether spiritual things have a measure proper [to them].
Second, whether they have a single measure.
Third, whether they have a simple or a composite measure — that is, a standing or a successive [one].
---
- 1In Vat. additur ex auctoritatibus.In the Vatican [edition] is added: ex auctoritatibus ["from [the] authorities"].
St. Bonaventure, Commentarius in II librum Sententiarum, Dist. 2, Part 1, Divisio Textus, in Opera Omnia (Quaracchi, 1885), tom. II, p. 54.
English translation: Wroot Press, Bonaventure Opera Omnia Translation Project, bonaventure.wrootpress.com/sentences/2/d2/p1-divisio. Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0.