← Back to Capitulum XV

Cap. 15, Vers. 12-17

Commentarius in Evangelium S. Ioannis · Capitulum XV

Contents
  1. Second he exhorts the disciples to the dilection of friends.
  2. Questions.
Textus Latinus
English Translation
p. 450

Secundo hortatur discipulos ad dilectionem amicorum.

19. Hoc est praeceptum meum. Postquam hortatus est Dominus ad dilectionem Dei, hic secundo hortatur ad dilectionem fratris et amici5, et hoc quidem facit per hunc modum. Primo ad dilectionem fraternam astringit intuitu obedientiae; secundo, intuitu divinae amicitiae; tertio, intuitu remunerationis aeternae.

(Vers. 12.). Astringit primo praecepto obedientiae, innuens, hoc esse omnino in voluntate sua tanquam praecipuum; propter quod dicit: Hoc est praeceptum meum, ut diligatis invicem; unde supra decimo tertio6: « Mandatum novum do vobis, ut diligatis invicem ». Et modus subiungitur: Sicut dilexi vos, « non verbo vel lingua, sed opere et veritate », sicut ego vos. Et quod ipse opere dilexerit eos, monstrat:

20. (Vers. 13.). Maiorem, inquit, hac dilectionem nemo habet, quam ut animam suam ponat quis7 pro amicis suis; quasi dicat: nihil plus potest facere quam vitam dare, quae omnibus carior est; ad Ephesios quinto: « Christus dilexit nos et tradidit semetipsum pro nobis oblationem et hostiam Deo in odorem suavitatis ». Et haec fuit vehementissima dilectio, non solum in Christo, qui tradidit se et animam suam, sed in Patre; unde ad Romanos octavo: « Qui proprio Filio non pepercit, sed pro nobis omnibus tradidit illum; quomodo non etiam cum illo omnia nobis donavit » ?

Unde notandum, quod magna est dilectio, qua mater diligit filium; super hanc dilexit nos Christus; Isaiae quadragesimo nono8: « Nunquid oblivisci potest mulier infantem suum, ut non misereatur filio uteri sui? Et si illa oblita fuerit, ego tamen non obliviscar tui ». — Maior, qua uxor virum, et super hanc Christus; Ieremiae tertio9: « Vulgo dicitur: Si dimiserit vir uxorem suam, et recedens ab eo duxerit virum alterum; nunquid revertetur ad eum ultra? Tu autem fornicata es cum amatoribus multis; tamen revertere, et ego suscipiam te ». — Maxima animae ad corpus; et super hanc dilexit nos; Ieremiae duodecimo10: « Reliqui domum meam, dimisi hereditatem meam, dedi dilectam animam meam in manus inimicorum eius ». Et ideo verum est il- p. 451 lud Canticorum ultimo: « Fortis est ut mors dilectio » etc.

21. (Vers. 14.). Vos amici mei estis. Hic secundo hortatur ad dilectionem mutuam intuitu divinae amicitiae; unde offert amicitiam suam his qui servant praecepta sua, ut iuxta Domini praeceptum invicem diligant; propter quod dicit: Vos amici mei estis, si feceritis quae1 praecipio vobis. Magnum quid promittit, cum amicitiam promittit. Augustinus: « Magna est dignatio Domini, cum nos amicos vocare dignatus est », cum sit amicus nomen paritatis; « est enim amicitia divinarum humanarumque rerum pari cum voluntate consensio ». Si enim sapientia amicos Dei constituit; Sapientiae septimo2: « In animas sanctas se transfert et amicos Dei constituit »; quanto magis dilectio? Haec dilectio probatur in opere; ideo dicit: Amici estis, si feceritis quae ego praecipio, ex amore ut amici, non ex timore ut servi, quia non estis vocati in servitutem; propter quod dicit:

22. (Vers. 15.). Iam non dicam vos servos, licet prius fueritis; ad Romanos octavo3: « Non accepistis spiritum servitutis iterum in timore, sed spiritum adoptionis filiorum ». Et per signum hoc ostendit: Quia servus nescit, quid faciat Dominus eius; vos autem non sic; ideo dicit: Vos autem dixi amicos, quia omnia, quaecumque audivi a Patre meo, nota feci vobis. Hoc signum magnae amicitiae, revelatio secretorum; ad Ephesios primo4: « Notum fecit nobis sacramentum voluntatis suae »; Matthaei decimo tertio: « Vobis datum est nosse mysteria regni Dei » etc.

23. (Vers. 16.). Non vos me elegistis. Hic tertio hortatur ad dilectionem intuitu remunerationis aeternae, ad quam per praedestinationem aeternam vocati erant, non per se venerant. Propterea dicit: Non vos me elegistis, sed ego elegi vos; ad Ephesios primo5: « Elegit nos ante mundi constitutionem, ut essemus sancti et immaculati in conspectu eius in caritate; qui praedestinavit nos in adoptionem filiorum per Iesum Christum in ipsum, secundum propositum voluntatis suae ». Ad quid elegerit, subdit: Et posui vos, ut eatis et fructum afferatis, in aliorum conversione; quod fit per praedicationem verbi Dei, quod est tanquam semen, quod fructum affert, quando recipitur in terram bonam; unde Lucae octavo6: « Quod vero in terram bonam, hi sunt, qui corde bono et optimo audiunt verbum et fructum afferunt in patientia »; primae Petri primo: « Renati non ex semine corruptibili, sed incorruptibili, per verbum Dei vivi et permanentis in aeternum ». Et fructus vester maneat, ad vestram salutem et consolationem per divinam remunerationem; et subiungitur remuneratio: Ut quodcumque petieritis Patrem in nomine meo, id est, quod sit ad vestram salutem, det vobis. Hoc autem, quod est petendum, est nostra salus; unde Matthaei sexto7: « Quaerite primum regnum Dei et iustitiam eius, et haec omnia adiicientur vobis ». Sic petebat illa sancta anima in Psalmo: « Unam petii a Domino, hanc requiram, ut inhabitem in domo Domini omnibus diebus vitae meae ». Et intuitu huius remunerationis debent mandatum Christi servare; ideo illud iterat:

24. (Vers. 17.). Haec mando vobis, ut diligatis invicem. Mandatum dilectionis dicitur quasi manu datum, quia exemplo suo dedit; ideo supra decimo tertio8: « Mandatum novum do vobis, ut diligatis invicem »; et primae ad Thessalonicenses quarto: « De caritate fraternitatis non habemus necesse scribere vobis; ipsi enim vos a Deo didicistis, ut diligatis invicem ».

Quaestiones.

25. Quaest. I. Sed quaerit Gregorius9 primo de hoc quod dicit: Hoc est praeceptum meum, ut diligatis invicem: « Cum cuncta divina eloquia dominicis sint plena praeceptis, quid est, quod de dilectione singulariter dicit: Hoc est praeceptum meum » ?

Et respondet, quod « divina praecepta multa sunt et unum: multa per diversitatem operis, unum in radice dilectionis ». Et dilectionem radicem dicit, « quia non habet viriditatem ramusculus boni operis, nisi manserit in radice dilectionis ». Quia ergo mandata ad praeceptum dilectionis referuntur, in quo omnia uniuntur et implentur; inde est, quod dicit: Hoc est praeceptum meum, singulariter.

26. Quaest. II. Item quaeritur de hoc quod dicit: Maiorem hac dilectionem nemo habet, quam ut animam suam ponat quis pro amicis suis.

Contra: 1. Ex parva caritate alius facit, alius ex maiori potest mori pro amico; quid est ergo, quod dicit maiorem? p. 452

2. Item, in patria erit multo maior caritas, quam sit in via; quid est ergo, quod dicit maiorem caritatem etc. ?

Respondeo, quod hoc non dicitur quantum ad habitum caritatis, vel actum eius praecipuum; sed quantum ad signum vel effectum, quia hoc est praecipuum signum dilectionis1.

27. Quaest. III. Sed tunc obiicitur: quia maius est pro inimico mori quam pro amico: ergo adhuc non est maximum signum dilectionis mori pro amico; unde arguit Apostolus ad Romanos quinto2 per locum a minori: Si, cum inimici essemus, reconciliati sumus Deo per mortem Filii eius; multo magis reconciliati salvi erimus in vita ipsius.

Ad hoc respondet Gregorius3, quod hoc nomen amicis non tantum supponit pro his qui Dominum diligebant, sed etiam pro inimicis, quia amici Domini erant, quoniam Dominus eos amabat, dum pro eis animam suam ponebat.

Vel intelligendum, quod Dominus loquebatur de dilectione amicorum, et quantum ad illam dilectionem nullum maius signum quam mori pro amico; similiter quantum ad dilectionem inimicorum veram; nam nullum maius signum quam mori pro inimico. Unde non notatur hic excessus simpliciter, sed in genere4.

28. Quaest. IV. Item quaeritur de hoc quod dicit: Iam non dicam vos servos.

Contra: 1. Matthaei vigesimo quinto5: Euge, serve bone et fidelis; et si vocat beatificandos servos, quid est ergo, quod dicit: Non dicam vos servos?

2. Item, supra decimo tertio6 dixit se dominum eorum: ergo a relativis et illos dixit servos.

Respondeo: Dicendum, quod servus dicitur dupliciter: uno modo, prout dicit obedientiam et subiectionem; et sic servus non distinguitur contra amicum, et sic omnes amici Dei sunt servi eius. Alio modo servus dicitur serviliter timens; et talis, qui solo timore servit, amicus non est; et de tali hic loquitur, quia nolebat, quod mandata eius serviliter implerent, sed potius amicabiliter7.

29. Quaest. V. Item quaeritur de hoc quod dicit: Omnia, quaecumque audivi a Patre meo, nota feci vobis. — Contra: Audivit Filius a Patre infinita, ergo nota fecit infinita.

Respondent, quod non loquitur de his quae audivit secundum quod Deus, sed secundum quod homo8.

Obiicitur tunc: quia diem iudicii homo Christus novit, tamen discipulis revelare noluit9. — Propter hoc respondent ultra, quod omnia pertinentia ad salutem. — Contra: infra decimo sexto10: Adhuc multa habeo vobis dicere, quae non potestis portare modo; et constat, quod ad eorum salutem: ergo etc.

Respondet Augustinus11: Omnia nota fecit, id est, disposuit nota facere; sic enim frequenter loquitur Scriptura, ponens praeteritum pro futuro in signum certitudinis. — Vel: omnia necessaria ad salu- p. 453 tem, secundum quod capere poterant1. — Et sic patent omnia.

30. Quaest. VI. Item quaeritur de hoc quod dicit: Non vos me elegistis.

Contra: 1. Deuteronomii vigesimo sexto2: Dominum elegisti, ut sit tibi Deus.

2. Item, si meritum liberi arbitrii consistit in electione3, quomodo merebantur, si ipsum non elegerant?

Respondeo: Quod hoc intelligendum est: primo, quia non primo nos eligimus Dominum, sed secundo; quia ipse prius elegit praedestinando et postmodum eligit ex aliis vocando, sed nos postmodum eligimus vocationi consentiendo4.

---

p. 450

Second he exhorts the disciples to the dilection of friends.

19. This is my precept. After the Lord has exhorted to the dilection of God, here second he exhorts to the dilection of a brother and friend5, and this indeed he does in this way. First he binds to fraternal dilection in view of obedience; second, in view of divine friendship; third, in view of eternal remuneration.

(Vers. 12.). He binds first by the precept of obedience, hinting that this is altogether in his will as the chief thing; on account of which he says: This is my precept, that you love one another; hence above, the thirteenth chapter6: « A new commandment I give unto you, that you love one another ». And the mode is subjoined: As I have loved you, « not in word, nor in tongue, but in deed, and in truth », as I you. And that he himself loved them in deed, he shows:

20. (Vers. 13.). Greater, he says, dilection than this no man hath, than that a man7 lay down his soul for his friends; as if to say: nothing more can he do than give life, which is dearer than all things; to the Ephesians, the fifth chapter: « Christ hath loved us, and hath delivered himself for us, an oblation and a sacrifice to God for an odour of sweetness ». And this was a most vehement dilection, not only in Christ, who delivered himself and his soul, but in the Father; hence to the Romans, the eighth chapter: « He that spared not his own Son, but delivered him up for us all, how hath he not also, with him, given us all things » ?

Hence it is to be noted that great is the dilection by which a mother loves her son; above this Christ has loved us; Isaias, the forty-ninth chapter8: « Can a woman forget her infant, so as not to have pity on the son of her womb? And if she should forget, yet will not I forget thee ». — Greater, that by which a wife loves her husband, and above this Christ; Jeremias, the third chapter9: « It is commonly said: If a man put away his wife, and she go from him, and marry another man, shall she return to him any more? But thou hast prostituted thyself to many lovers; nevertheless return, and I will receive thee ». — Greatest, that of the soul for the body; and above this he has loved us; Jeremias, the twelfth chapter10: « I have forsaken my house, I have left my inheritance: I have given my dear soul into the hands of her enemies ». And therefore true is that p. 451 word, the Canticles, the last chapter: « Dilection is strong as death » etc.

21. (Vers. 14.). You are my friends. Here second he exhorts to mutual dilection in view of divine friendship; hence he offers his friendship to those who keep his precepts, that according to the Lord's precept they may love one another; on account of which he says: You are my friends, if you do the things that1 I command you. Something great he promises, when he promises friendship. Augustine: « Great is the condescension of the Lord, when he has condescended to call us friends », since friend is a name of parity; « for friendship is an accord of divine and human matters with equal will ». For if wisdom makes friends of God; Wisdom, the seventh chapter2: « Into holy souls she conveyeth herself, and maketh the friends of God »; how much more dilection? This dilection is proved in the deed; therefore he says: You are friends, if you do the things that I command, out of love as friends, not out of fear as servants, because you have not been called into servitude; on account of which he says:

22. (Vers. 15.). I will not now call you servants, although formerly you were; to the Romans, the eighth chapter3: « You have not received the spirit of servitude again in fear, but the spirit of adoption of sons ». And he shows this by a sign: Because the servant knoweth not what his Lord doth; but you not so; therefore he says: But I have called you friends, because all things whatsoever I have heard of my Father, I have made known to you. This is the sign of a great friendship, the revelation of secrets; to the Ephesians, the first chapter4: « He hath made known to us the sacrament of his will »; Matthew, the thirteenth chapter: « To you it is given to know the mysteries of the kingdom of God » etc.

23. (Vers. 16.). You have not chosen me. Here third he exhorts to dilection in view of eternal remuneration, to which they had been called by eternal predestination, and had not come of themselves. Therefore he says: You have not chosen me, but I have chosen you; to the Ephesians, the first chapter5: « He chose us before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and unspotted in his sight in charity; who hath predestinated us unto the adoption of children through Jesus Christ unto himself, according to the purpose of his will ». To what he has chosen them, he subjoins: And I have appointed you, that you should go and should bring forth fruit, in the conversion of others; which comes about through the preaching of the word of God, which is as a seed, which brings forth fruit, when it is received into good ground; hence Luke, the eighth chapter6: « But that on the good ground, are they who in a good and perfect heart hear the word and bring forth fruit in patience »; the first of Peter, the first chapter: « Being born again not of corruptible seed, but incorruptible, by the word of God who liveth and remaineth for ever ». And your fruit should remain, for your salvation and consolation through divine remuneration; and the remuneration is subjoined: That whatsoever you shall ask of the Father in my name, that is, what may be for your salvation, he may give you. But this, which is to be asked, is our salvation; hence Matthew, the sixth chapter7: « Seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his justice, and all these things shall be added unto you ». So that holy soul was asking in the Psalm: « One thing I have asked of the Lord, this will I seek after; that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life ». And in view of this remuneration they ought to keep the commandment of Christ; therefore he repeats it:

24. (Vers. 17.). These things I command you, that you love one another. The commandment (mandatum) of dilection is so called as it were given by hand (manu datum), because he gave it by his example; therefore above, the thirteenth chapter8: « A new commandment I give unto you, that you love one another »; and the first to the Thessalonians, the fourth chapter: « Of the charity of brotherhood we have no need to write to you; for you yourselves have learned of God to love one another ».

Questions.

25. Quaest. I. But Gregory9 asks first concerning this which he says: This is my precept, that you love one another: « Since all the divine utterances are full of the Lord's precepts, what is it that of dilection he says singularly: This is my precept » ?

And he responds that « the divine precepts are many and one: many through the diversity of the work, one in the root of dilection ». And he calls dilection the root, « because the little bough of good work has no greenness, unless it abides in the root of dilection ». Since, then, the commandments are referred to the precept of dilection, in which all are united and fulfilled; thence it is that he says: This is my precept, singularly.

26. Quaest. II. Likewise it is asked concerning this which he says: Greater dilection than this no man hath, than that a man lay down his soul for his friends.

On the contrary: 1. Out of small charity one does it, another out of greater can die for a friend; what is it, then, that he says greater? p. 452

2. Likewise, in the fatherland there will be much greater charity than there is on the way; what is it, then, that he says greater charity etc. ?

I respond that this is not said as to the habit of charity, or its chief act; but as to the sign or effect, because this is the chief sign of dilection1.

27. Quaest. III. But then it is objected: because it is greater to die for an enemy than for a friend: therefore it is not yet the greatest sign of dilection to die for a friend; hence the Apostle argues, to the Romans, the fifth chapter2, by the topic from the lesser: If, when we were enemies, we were reconciled to God by the death of his Son; much more, being reconciled, shall we be saved by his life.

To this Gregory3 responds that this noun friends supposits not only for those who loved the Lord, but also for enemies, because they were friends of the Lord, since the Lord loved them, while he was laying down his soul for them.

Or it is to be understood that the Lord was speaking of the dilection of friends, and as to that dilection there is no greater sign than to die for a friend; likewise as to true dilection of enemies; for there is no greater sign than to die for an enemy. Hence no excess is noted here simply, but in its genus4.

28. Quaest. IV. Likewise it is asked concerning this which he says: I will not now call you servants.

On the contrary: 1. Matthew, the twenty-fifth chapter5: Well done, good and faithful servant; and if he calls those to be beatified servants, what is it, then, that he says: I will not call you servants?

2. Likewise, above, the thirteenth chapter6, he said that he was their lord: therefore from relatives he also said that they were servants.

I respond: It must be said that servant is said in two ways: in one way, as it says obedience and subjection; and so a servant is not distinguished against a friend, and so all the friends of God are his servants. In another way a servant is said as one servilely fearing; and such a one, who serves by fear alone, is not a friend; and of such a one he speaks here, because he did not want them to fulfil his commandments servilely, but rather amicably7.

29. Quaest. V. Likewise it is asked concerning this which he says: All things whatsoever I have heard of my Father, I have made known to you. — On the contrary: The Son has heard infinite things from the Father, therefore he has made known infinite things.

They respond that he is not speaking of those things which he heard according as he is God, but according as he is man8.

It is objected then: because Christ as man knew the day of judgement, yet he was unwilling to reveal it to the disciples9. — On account of this they respond further, that it means all things pertaining to salvation. — On the contrary: below, the sixteenth chapter10: I have yet many things to say to you, which you cannot bear now; and it is established that they were for their salvation: therefore etc.

Augustine responds11: He has made all things known, that is, he disposed to make them known; for so Scripture frequently speaks, setting the past for the future as a sign of certitude. — Or: all things necessary for salva- p. 453 tion, according as they were able to take them in1. — And thus all things are evident.

30. Quaest. VI. Likewise it is asked concerning this which he says: You have not chosen me.

On the contrary: 1. Deuteronomy, the twenty-sixth chapter2: Thou hast chosen the Lord to be thy God.

2. Likewise, if the merit of free choice consists in election3, how did they merit, if they had not chosen him?

I respond: That this is to be understood: first, because we do not choose the Lord first, but second; because he first chose by predestining and afterward chooses out of others by calling, but we afterward choose by consenting to the calling4.

---

Apparatus Criticus
  1. 5
    Cfr. supra n. 1.
    Cf. above, n. 1.
  2. 6
    Vers. 34; sequitur I. Ioan. 3, 18.
    Verse 34; there follows I John 3:18.
  3. 7
    Vulgata omittit in hac propositione quam. — Subinde allegantur Eph. 5, 2. et Rom. 8, 32.
    The Vulgate omits in this proposition quam ("than"). — Immediately after are cited Eph. 5:2 and Rom. 8:32.
  4. 8
    Vers. 15.
    Verse 15.
  5. 9
    Vers. 1, ubi Vulgata post ultra plura addit.
    Verse 1, where the Vulgate after ultra ("any more") adds further matter.
  6. 10
    Vers. 7. — Sequitur Cant. 8, 6. Cfr. infra n. 26. et 27.
    Verse 7. — There follows Cant. 8:6. Cf. below, nn. 26 and 27.
  7. 1
    Vulgata addit ego. — Sententia August. habetur in Ioan. Evang. tr. 85. n. 1: « Magna dignatio... Sed, ut dixi, ista dignatio est, ut Dominus quos novit servos suos dignetur dicere amicos suos ». Subinde sequitur definitio amicitiae ex Cicerone, lib. de Amicitia, c. 6; cfr. tom. I. pag. 857, nota 3.
    The Vulgate adds ego ("I"). — Augustine's statement is found in On the Gospel of John, tr. 85, n. 1: « Great condescension... But, as I have said, this is the condescension, that the Lord should condescend to call those whom he knows to be his servants his friends ». Immediately after follows the definition of friendship from Cicero, book On Friendship, c. 6; cf. vol. I, p. 857, note 3.
  8. 2
    Vers. 27. — Inferius Vulgata legit: Vos amici... praecipio vobis.
    Verse 27. — Below, the Vulgate reads: Vos amici... praecipio vobis ("You friends... I command you").
  9. 3
    Vers. 15. Cfr. Gal. 4, 5. et II. Tim. 1, 7.
    Verse 15. Cf. Gal. 4:5 and II Tim. 1:7.
  10. 4
    Vers. 9; cfr. v. 11. — Subinde allegatur Matth. 13, 11. Cfr. II. Sent. d. 29. a. 2. q. 1. ad 5. — Superius pro magnae plures codd. magnum.
    Verse 9; cf. v. 11. — Immediately after is cited Matt. 13:11. Cf. II Sent. d. 29, a. 2, q. 1, ad 5. — Above, for magnae ("of a great") several codices have magnum ("a great").
  11. 5
    Vers. 4. seq. Cfr. supra Comment. in Sap. 4, 15. in fine. — Superius post ad quam codd. omittunt per praedestinationem.
    Verse 4 f. Cf. above, Commentary on Wisdom 4:15, at the end. — Above, after ad quam ("to which") the codices omit per praedestinationem ("by predestination").
  12. 6
    Vers. 15. — Sequitur I. Petr. 1, 23. — Gregor., II. Homil. in Evang. homil. 27. n. 5: Posui, ad gratiam plantavi, ut eatis, volendo, fructum afferatis, operando. Eatis enim volendo, dixi, quia velle aliquid facere iam mente ire est. Qualem vero fructum afferre debeant, subditur: Et fructus vester maneat etc.
    Verse 15. — There follows I Pet. 1:23. — Gregory, II Homilies on the Gospels, homily 27, n. 5: I have appointed, I have planted in grace, that you should go, by willing, should bring forth fruit, by working. That you should go by willing, I have said, because to will to do something is already to go in the mind. But what fruit they ought to bring forth is subjoined: And your fruit should remain etc.
  13. 7
    Vers. 33. — Subinde allegatur Ps. 26, 4.
    Verse 33. — Immediately after is cited Ps. 26:4.
  14. 8
    Vers. 34. — Sequitur I. Thess. 4, 9. — Isidor., V. Etymolog. c. 24. n. 20: Mandatum dictum, quod olim in commisso negotio alter alteri manum dabat.
    Verse 34. — There follows I Thess. 4:9. — Isidore, V Etymologies, c. 24, n. 20: Mandatum ("commandment") is so called because of old, in a business entrusted, one gave his hand to the other.
  15. 9
    Libr. II. Homil. in Evang. homil. 27. n. 1, ubi etiam responsio seq. habetur, in qua pro ramusculus textus originalis ramus.
    Book II of the Homilies on the Gospels, homily 27, n. 1, where the following response also is found, in which for ramusculus ("little bough") the original text has ramus ("bough").
  16. 1
    Glossa interlinearis in hunc locum: Ponere animam pro amicis non est dilectio, sed effectus dilectionis. Cfr. I. Sent. d. 17. p. I. dub. 7: Hoc [Dominus] dicit quantum ad signum et exteriorem ostensionem. Vide etiam II. Sent. d. 28. a. 1. q. 3. ad 5.
    The interlinear Gloss on this place: To lay down one's soul for friends is not dilection, but an effect of dilection. Cf. I Sent. d. 17, p. I, dub. 7: This [the Lord] says as to the sign and exterior showing. See also II Sent. d. 28, a. 1, q. 3, ad 5.
  17. 2
    Vers. 10. — Bernard., Serm. de passione Domini, in feria IV. hebdomadae sanctae, n. 4: Tu maiorem habuisti, Domine, ponens eam etiam pro inimicis. Cum enim adhuc inimici essemus, per mortem tuam et tibi reconciliati sumus et Patri.
    Verse 10. — Bernard, Sermon on the Passion of the Lord, on Wednesday of Holy Week, n. 4: Thou hast had a greater, O Lord, laying it down even for enemies. For when we were yet enemies, by thy death we were reconciled both to thee and to the Father.
  18. 3
    Libr. II. Homil. in Evang. homil. 27. n. 2: Mori etiam pro inimicis Dominus venerat, et tamen positurum se animam pro amicis dicebat, ut profecto nobis ostenderet, quia, dum diligendo lucrum facere de inimicis possumus, etiam ipsi amici sunt, qui persequuntur. — Inferius respicitur Ioan. 10, 15: Animam meam pono pro ovibus meis.
    Book II of the Homilies on the Gospels, homily 27, n. 2: The Lord had come to die even for enemies, and yet he said that he would lay down his soul for friends, that he might surely show us that, while by loving we are able to make gain from enemies, even those are friends who persecute. — Below, regard is had to John 10:15: I lay down my soul for my sheep.
  19. 4
    Aristot., V. Metaph. text. 21. (IV. c. 16.): Quaedam [dicuntur perfecta], eo quod secundum bene in nullo deficiunt nec habent in aliquo genere excessum, nec est quidquam extra; quaedam, eo quod omnino in unoquoque genere excessum non habent, nec quidquam est extra. Cfr. III. Sent. d. 30. q. 6, ubi inquiritur: Utrum sit maioris perfectionis et meriti diligere amicum, an diligere inimicum.
    Aristotle, V Metaphysics, text 21 (IV, c. 16): Some things [are said to be perfect] because according to good they are deficient in nothing and have no excess in any genus, nor is anything outside them; others, because altogether they have no excess in each genus, nor is anything outside them. Cf. III Sent. d. 30, q. 6, where it is inquired: Whether it is of greater perfection and merit to love a friend, or to love an enemy.
  20. 5
    Vers. 21.
    Verse 21.
  21. 6
    Vers. 13-15. — Boeth., III. de Differentiis topic., hanc maximam pro loco a relativis statuit: « In relativis autem absque se relativa esse non posse ». Cfr. Aristot., de Praedicam. c. de his quae ad aliquid (i. e. relativis), ubi etiam occurrit, quod converti possint: servus domini servus, et: dominus servi dominus.
    Verses 13–15. — Boethius, III On Topical Differences, lays down this maxim for the topic from relatives: « But in relatives, that relatives cannot be without one another ». Cf. Aristotle, Categories, c. on those things which are toward something (that is, relatives), where it also occurs that they can be converted: the servant is the servant of a lord, and: the lord is the lord of a servant.
  22. 7
    August., in Ioan. Evang. tr. 85. n. 3: Sicut enim duo sunt timores, qui faciunt duo genera timentium, sic duae sunt servitutes, quae faciunt duo genera servorum. Est timor, quem perfecta caritas foras mittit [I. Ioan. 4, 18.], et est alius timor castus, permanens in saeculum saeculi [Ps. 18, 10.]... In illo timore, quem foras caritas mittit, est etiam servitus simul foras cum ipso timore mittenda; utrumque enim iunxit Apostolus [Rom. 8, 15.], hoc est servitutem et timorem, dicendo: Non enim accepistis spiritum servitutis iterum in timore. Ad hanc servitutem servum pertinentem intuebatur et Dominus dicens: Iam non dico vos servos, quia servus nescit, quid faciat dominus eius. Non utique ille servus pertinens ad timorem castum, cui dicitur [Matth. 25, 21.]: Euge, serve bone, intra in gaudium Domini tui etc. Cfr. III. Sent. lit. Magistri, d. XXXIV. c. 4. seqq., et ibid. Comment. p. II. per totam.
    Augustine, On the Gospel of John, tr. 85, n. 3: For as there are two fears, which make two kinds of those who fear, so there are two servitudes, which make two kinds of servants. There is the fear which perfect charity casteth out [I John 4:18], and there is another, chaste fear, enduring for ever and ever [Ps. 18:10]... In that fear which charity casteth out, servitude also is to be cast out together with the fear itself; for the Apostle has joined both [Rom. 8:15], that is, servitude and fear, saying: For you have not received the spirit of servitude again in fear. To this servitude the Lord too was looking at the servant who pertains to it, saying: I do not now call you servants, because the servant knoweth not what his lord doth. Certainly not that servant who pertains to chaste fear, to whom it is said [Matt. 25:21]: Well done, good servant, enter into the joy of thy lord etc. Cf. III Sent., the Master's text, d. XXXIV, c. 4 ff., and in the same place the Commentary, p. II, throughout.
  23. 8
    Hanc et seq. responsionem insinuat Glossa interlinearis: Quaecumque audivi, ego homo ad opus hominum.
    This and the following response the interlinear Gloss intimates: Whatsoever I have heard, I as man for the use of men.
  24. 9
    Vide Matth. 24, 36, de cuius expositione cfr. tom. III. pag. 304, nota 9. et tom. IV. pag. 989, nota 1. — Seq. responsionem exhibet S. Doctor IV. Sent. d. 48. a. 1. q. 4. ad 2. — Inferius post salutem ed. cum Gorrano addit eis revelaverit.
    See Matt. 24:36, on the exposition of which cf. vol. III, p. 304, note 9, and vol. IV, p. 989, note 1. — The following response the Holy Doctor gives at IV Sent. d. 48, a. 1, q. 4, ad 2. — Below, after salutem ("salvation") the edition with Gorran adds eis revelaverit ("he revealed to them").
  25. 10
    Vers. 12.
    Verse 12.
  26. 11
    In Ioan. Evang. tr. 86. n. 1: Sed nimirum, quod facturus est, fecisse se dicit, qui ea quae futura sunt fecit [Isai. 45, 11. secundum Septuaginta; cfr. supra pag. 436, nota 1.]. Sicut enim dicit per Prophetam [Ps. 21, 18.]: Foderunt manus meas et pedes meos, nec ait: fossuri sunt, velut praeterita dicens, et ea tamen futura praedicens; ita et hoc loco ait, omnia se nota fecisse discipulis, quae se novit nota esse facturum in illa plenitudine scientiae, de qua dicit Apostolus [I. Cor. 13, 10.]: Cum autem venerit quod perfectum est, quod ex parte est evacuabitur etc.
    On the Gospel of John, tr. 86, n. 1: But assuredly, he says that he has done what he is going to do, he who has done the things that are to come [Isa. 45:11 according to the Septuagint; cf. above, p. 436, note 1]. For as he says through the Prophet [Ps. 21:18]: They have dug my hands and my feet, and does not say: they will dig, as if speaking of things past, and yet foretelling things to come; so in this place too he says that he has made known to the disciples all things which he knows that he will make known in that fullness of knowledge, of which the Apostle says [I Cor. 13:10]: But when that which is perfect is come, that which is in part shall be done away etc.
  27. 1
    Chrysost., in Ioan. homil. 77. (alias 76.) n. 1: Cum vero dicit omnia, intelligas ea quae audire illos oportebat. Theophylact., in Ioan. 15, 15: Omnia nota fecit eis, quae illi poterant audire et quorum erant capaces.
    Chrysostom, On John, homily 77 (otherwise 76), n. 1: But when he says all things, you are to understand those things which it was fitting for them to hear. Theophylact, On John 15:15: He made known to them all things which they were able to hear and of which they were capable.
  28. 2
    Vers. 17.
    Verse 17.
  29. 3
    Cfr. Damasc., II. de Fide orthod. c. 22, ubi electio tanquam ultimus actus voluntatis in ordine intentionis respectu finis per media assequendi assignatur, et definitur, quod « nihil est aliud nisi e duabus rebus, quae proponuntur, alterius prae altera susceptio ». — Infra post intelligendum est ed. omittit primo.
    Cf. Damascene, II On the Orthodox Faith, c. 22, where election is assigned as the last act of the will in the order of intention with respect to an end to be attained through means, and is defined thus, that « it is nothing else than, of two things which are proposed, the taking up of one in preference to the other ». — Below, after intelligendum est ("is to be understood") the edition omits primo ("first").
  30. 4
    Secundum August., in Ioan. Evang. tr. 86. n. 2. et de Praedestinat. Sanctorum, c. 17. n. 34. Cfr. I. Sent. d. 40. a. 3. q. 1. et 2. — Ed. libere consentiendo.
    According to Augustine, On the Gospel of John, tr. 86, n. 2, and On the Predestination of the Saints, c. 17, n. 34. Cf. I Sent. d. 40, a. 3, qq. 1 and 2. — The edition has libere consentiendo ("by freely consenting").
Cite this

St. Bonaventure, Commentarius in Evangelium S. Ioannis, Cap. 15, Vers. 12-17, in Opera Omnia (Quaracchi, 1893), tom. VI, pp. 450–453.

English translation: Wroot Press, Bonaventure Opera Omnia Translation Project, bonaventure.wrootpress.com/ioannem/c15-v12-17. Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0.

Authorities cited here

Aristotle, Categoriae (Praedicamenta), Metaphysica · Augustine of Hippo, De praedestinatione sanctorum, In Ioannis Evangelium tractatus (4) · Bernard of Clairvaux, Sermones · Boethius, De differentiis topicis · Gregory the Great, Homiliae in Evangelia (3) · Isidore of Seville, Etymologiae · John Chrysostom, Homiliae in Ioannem · John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa · The Gloss (Glossa ordinaria / interlinearis), Glossa interlinearis (2) · Theophylact of Ohrid, Enarratio in Ioannem