← Back to Distinction 2

Dist. 2, Part 2, Art. 1, Q. 2

Book II: On the Creation of Things · Distinction 2

Textus Latinus
English Translation
p. 73

Quaestio II. Utrum caelum empyreum influat in haec inferiora.

Secundo quaeritur de empyreo quantum ad virtutem influentiae. Et quaeritur, utrum empyreum influat in haec inferiora, an non. Et quod sic, videtur.

1. In quolibet creato, quod est perfectum et completum, est substantia, virtus et operatio1: ergo in ipso empyreo. Si ergo habet virtutem, aut operatur in id quod supra, vel in id quod iuxta, vel in id quod infra. Non in id quod supra, planum est; nec in id quod iuxta, quia ipsum est supra omnia corpora: ergo videtur, quod per illam virtutem influit in id quod infra; aut virtus et substantia eius erit otiosa, quod est plane inconveniens.

2. Item, omnia corpora propter humanum obsequium sunt facta, unde «sumus nos finis quodam modo omnium eorum quae sunt2»: ergo si empyreum aliquid est, de aliquo servit homini; sed hoc non faceret, nisi aliquid in haec inferiora influeret: ergo etc.

3. Item, quanto aliquod corpus situ est superius, tanto inter corpora nobilius est3, et quanto nobilius, tanto potentius et melius, et quanto potentius et melius, tanto in agendo et influendo efficacius: si ergo caelum empyreum est supremum, ergo videtur, quod sit maxime influens in haec inferiora.

4. Item, quanto lumen4 est maius, tanto magis se diffundit et multiplicat: si ergo empyreum inter corpora est luminosum maxime, ergo maxime diffusivum; sed lumen illud non privatur efficacia vegetandi et conservandi, quemadmodum nec lumen firmamenti: ergo videtur, quod empyreum in haec inferiora magis sit influens.

Contra:

1. Influentia caelestis corporis maxime consistit in diffusione luminis et caloris; sed empyreum non calefacit5, nec ista corpora inferiora irradiat: ergo videtur, quod nulla sit influentia empyrei in haec inferiora.

2. Item, corpora, quae sunt infra firmamentum, sufficienter influunt ad vegetationem et generationem in his inferioribus faciendam: ergo «si natura nihil frustra facit6», videtur, quod alterius caeli influentia nulla sit, cum nullius sit opportunitatis.

3. Item, influentia caeli debet esse conformis ei a quo est, debet etiam nihilominus esse conformis ei a quo recipitur; sed caelum empyreum est p. 74incorruptibile, uniforme, quietissimum, statui et quieti gloriae deputatum, haec autem, quae infra sunt, habent omnino oppositas conditiones: ergo videtur, quod nullo modo super corpora inferiora influere habeat7.

4. Item, si influit super corpora, aut ergo ad nobiliorem effectum, quam sit influentia octavae sphaerae, aut ad minus nobilem, aut ad eundem effectum. Ad eundem non oportet; ad minus nobilem non decet, cum illud corpus sit nobilius; ad magis nobilem non potest: ergo nullo modo influit. Probatio: quod non possit in magis nobilem, videtur. Nam, sicut volunt philosophi et communiter tenent viri physici8, influentia caeli est operans ad productionem animae sensibilis; sed supra animam sensibilem non est nisi rationalis, haec autem nulli corpori est subiecta, immo est a creatione pura: ergo nullo modo potest eminentior esse influentia quam supra animam sensibilem; et supra hanc influit firmamentum sufficienter cum his quae sunt infra: ergo videtur, quod nulla sit influentia empyrei existentis supra. Si tu dicas, quod influit non ratione animae in se, sed ratione dispositionis a parte corporis; contra: anima rationalis unitur mediante vi sensitiva et vegetativa, et corpus disponitur ad susceptionem animae mediante complexione aequali et spiritu triplici, scilicet vitali, naturali et animali9; et ad haec omnia influit hoc caelum sidereum sufficienter: ergo redit idem quod prius.

Conclusio

Caelum empyreum in corpora inferiora aliquam habet influentiam.

Respondeo: Dicendum, quod circa hoc duplex fuit opinio.

Quidam namque dixerunt, quod caelum empyreum influit in haec inferiora, et influentia nobilissima. — Cum enim sit corpus, necesse est, influentiam suam, si qua est, esse corporalem. Rursus, cum sit excellentissimum inter corpora caelestia, influit super corpora nobilissima, et talia sunt corpora humana, quae sunt ordinata ad nobilissimam formam, scilicet animam rationalem, quae maiorem et nobiliorem dispositionem exigit in sua materia. Cum igitur natura lucis disponat ad vitam, et triplex sit vita secundum triplicem differentiam animae, differens gradu et dignitate; tres Deus condidit caelos ordinatos inter se gradu et dignitate, non solum naturae, sed etiam influentiae, ita quod caelum sidereum de se ordinatur ad conciliationem elementorum, ad susceptionem vegetabilis, crystallinum ad susceptionem sensibilis, sed empyreum ad susceptionem rationalis.

Et hoc quidem rationabile videtur non solum ratione ordinis influentiae, sed etiam ratione conformitatis naturae. Caelum enim empyreum est locus spiritualium substantiarum, locus etiam corporum glorificatorum. Et quoniam convenientia est loci ad locatum vel manifesta vel occulta, videtur influentia illius caeli esse consona corporibus nostris et animabus amica, non ratione sui, sed ratione suorum corporum, quae perficiunt et informant10.

Alia vero opinio fuit circa hoc omnino isti contraria, quae dixit, quod caeli empyrei in haec inferiora nulla est omnino influentia, quia non habent corpora influentiam nisi secundum ordinem Conditoris, habito respectu ad finem. Quoniam igitur empyreum ad perfectionem universi est conditum, et ut sit locus Beatorum, ideo regio illa11 et lux est a nobis remota et occulta, sicut et ipsa gloria, quam per gratiam exspectamus et amamus et credimus, licet non videamus. Et ideo dicunt, quod empyreum non est ad obsequium hominis in praesenti, sed ad obsequium perpetuum; nec melioratur, sed uniformiter in sua dignitate subsistit. Et ideo rationes adductae ad ostendendam influentiam12 in haec inferiora secundum hos non valent, quia ordinatio illius corporis ad aliud officium secundum dictamen et imperium Conditoris huiusmodi influentiam non admittit; et hoc solum omnes illas rationes dissolvit.

Quaelibet harum opinionum satis probabilis est; quae autem sit magis vera, non plane apparet. Quis enim novit, si Deus illi caelo hanc occultam influentiam dedit super corpora nostra tum ratione nobilitatis, tum ratione conformitatis? Hoc non est, ut credo, facile refellere nec per violentiam auctoritatis, nec per efficaciam rationis. Rursus, quae sit necessitas huius influentiae, nec ratio nec auctoritas manifestat, cum satis videatur sufficere aliorum inferiorum corporum influentia. — Ideo in neutram partem omnino declinando, dicendum videtur, quod cum caelum empyreum sit primum creatum inter corpora, quod est maximum mole et virtute: quia est maximum mole, omnia corpora13 locat per ambitum et continentiam; quia maximum p. 75virtute, cetera vegetat et conservat per suam influentiam. Omittendo igitur illam influentiam, quam dicitur habere super humana corpora, sustineri potest, quod aliquem effectum et aliquam influentiam habeat super corpora inferiora, tanquam primum creatum super sequentia. Et rationes ad hoc inductae sunt concedendae.

1. 2. Quod ergo obiicitur de influentia luminis et caloris, dicendum, quod influentia luminis potest esse dupliciter: vel manifesta, vel occulta. Manifesta influentia est per diaphanum corpus, maxime quando sensu percipitur. Occulta influentia est non solum per diaphanum corpus, sed etiam per opacum, sicut virtus stellarum est in mineralia, quae latent sub terra. — Vel potest dici, quod est influentia mediata et immediata; et possibile est, quod influentia caeli siderei vigoratur ex adiumento luminis superiorum caelorum, et virtutem susceptam desuperius derivat et transmittit ad haec inferiora; et videtur nobis esse propria illorum14, cum tamen non sit propria, sed etiam aliena. — Et per hoc patet aliud, quod non est causa sufficiens virtus inferiorum caelorum nisi per adiumentum superiorum.

3. Quod obiicitur de conformitate, dicendum, quod conformis est natura spiritus, qui disponit ad vitam, ipsi luci caelesti quantum ad puritatem; et hac ratione nata est recipere; sed non oportet in omnibus consonare.

4. Quod obiicitur, utrum ad nobiliorem effectum; dicendum secundum primam opinionem, quod ad nobiliorem effectum, quia ad generationem spirituum, qui sunt dispositio ad susceptionem15 animae rationalis. — Et si tu obiicias, quod non sunt alii, quam illi qui disponunt ad sensibilem: dicendum, quod etsi non sint omnino alii secundum formam, tamen sunt puriores et excellentioribus et nobilioribus potentiis nati ministrare, secundum quam etiam rationem nobiliorem oportet esse complexionem et organizationem tam humani corporis quam brutalis. — Potest tamen sustineri, quod ad eosdem effectus influunt, nec tamen alterum eorum superfluit, quia virtus caeli inferioris et influentia adiuvatur per virtutem superioris, et virtus superioris operatur mediante virtute et influentia inferioris; ideo neutrum superfluit, sed ad haec inferiora conservanda et perficienda virtus utriusque concurrit16.

---

Question II. Whether the empyrean heaven influences these lower things.

Secondly it is asked concerning the empyrean as to the power of [its] influence. And it is asked whether the empyrean influences these lower things, or not. And that [it does] so, it seems.

1. In everything created which is perfect and complete there is substance, power, and operation1: therefore [also] in the empyrean itself. If therefore it has power, it either operates on what is above, or on what is alongside, or on what is below. Not on what is above — that is plain; nor on what is alongside, because it itself is above all bodies: therefore it seems that through that power it influences what is below; or [else] its power and substance will be idle, which is plainly unfitting.

2. Likewise, all bodies were made for the service of man, whence «we are in a certain way the end of all the things which exist2»: therefore if the empyrean is anything, in some respect it serves man; but it would not do this unless it influenced something into these lower things: therefore etc.

3. Likewise, the higher in position some body is, the nobler it is among bodies3, and the nobler, the more powerful and better, and the more powerful and better, the more efficacious in acting and influencing: if therefore the empyrean heaven is the highest, then it seems that it is most of all influencing into these lower things.

4. Likewise, the greater the light4 is, the more it diffuses and multiplies itself: if therefore the empyrean among bodies is most of all luminous, then [it is] most of all diffusive; but that light is not deprived of the efficacy of vivifying and conserving, just as neither [is] the light of the firmament: therefore it seems that the empyrean influences these lower things more.

On the contrary:

1. The influence of a celestial body consists chiefly in the diffusion of light and heat; but the empyrean does not heat5, nor does it irradiate these lower bodies: therefore it seems that there is no influence of the empyrean into these lower things.

2. Likewise, the bodies which are below the firmament influence sufficiently for the vivification and generation to be done in these lower things: therefore «if nature does nothing in vain6», it seems that the influence of another heaven is null, since it is of no opportuneness.

3. Likewise, the influence of a heaven ought to be conformed to that from which it is, and ought nonetheless to be conformed to that by which it is received; but the empyrean heaven is p. 74incorruptible, uniform, most quiet, deputed to the state and rest of glory; but these [things] which are below have wholly opposite conditions: therefore it seems that it has in no way [the property] to influence over the lower bodies7.

4. Likewise, if it influences over bodies, then [it does so] either toward a nobler effect than the influence of the eighth sphere is, or toward a less noble, or toward the same effect. Toward the same — [that] is not fitting; toward a less noble — [that] is not becoming, since that body is nobler; toward a more noble — [that it] cannot: therefore in no way does it influence. Proof: that it cannot [influence] toward a more noble [effect], seems [so]. For, as the philosophers hold and the natural scientists commonly maintain8, the influence of a heaven is operative toward the production of the sensible soul; but above the sensible soul there is only the rational [soul], and this is subject to no body, indeed is from a pure creation: therefore in no way can there be an influence more eminent than over the sensible soul; and over this the starry [heaven] influences sufficiently with the things which are below: therefore it seems that there is no influence of the empyrean existing above. If you say that it influences not by reason of the soul in itself, but by reason of the disposition on the part of the body; on the contrary: the rational soul is united by means of the sensitive and vegetative power, and the body is disposed for the reception of the soul by means of an equal complexion and a threefold spirit, namely vital, natural, and animal9; and into all these the starry heaven influences sufficiently: therefore the same [conclusion] returns as before.

Conclusion

The empyrean heaven has some influence into the lower bodies.

I respond: It must be said that concerning this there was a twofold opinion.

For some said that the empyrean heaven influences these lower things, and [with] a most noble influence. — For since it is a body, its influence, if it has any, must necessarily be corporeal. Again, since it is the most excellent among the celestial bodies, it influences over the noblest bodies, and such are human bodies, which are ordered to the noblest form, namely the rational soul, which demands a greater and nobler disposition in its matter. Since therefore the nature of light disposes toward life, and life is threefold according to the threefold difference of the soul, differing in grade and dignity; God founded three heavens ordered among themselves in grade and dignity, not only of nature but also of influence, so that the starry heaven of itself is ordered to the conciliation of the elements, to the reception of the vegetable [soul], the crystalline to the reception of the sensible, but the empyrean to the reception of the rational.

And this indeed seems reasonable not only by reason of the order of influence, but also by reason of the conformity of nature. For the empyrean heaven is the place of spiritual substances, the place also of glorified bodies. And since the suitability of the place to what is located [there] is either manifest or hidden, the influence of that heaven seems to be consonant with our bodies and friendly to [our] souls, not by reason of itself, but by reason of their bodies, which perfect and inform10 [them].

But there was another opinion concerning this wholly contrary to that one, which said that of the empyrean heaven there is no influence at all into these lower things, because bodies do not have influence except according to the order of the Creator, regard being had to the end. Since therefore the empyrean was founded for the perfection of the universe, and that it might be the place of the Blessed, therefore that region11 and [its] light is remote and hidden from us, just as also is glory itself, which through grace we await and love and believe, although we do not see [it]. And therefore they say that the empyrean is not for the service of man in the present, but for perpetual service; nor is it bettered, but uniformly subsists in its dignity. And therefore the reasons adduced to show an influence12 into these lower things, according to these [men], do not hold, because the ordination of that body to another office, according to the dictate and command of the Creator, does not admit such an influence; and this alone dissolves all those reasons.

Each of these opinions is sufficiently probable; but which is the truer does not plainly appear. For who knows whether God gave to that heaven this hidden influence over our bodies both by reason of [its] nobility and by reason of conformity? This is not, as I believe, easy to refute, neither by the force of authority nor by the efficacy of reason. Again, what is the necessity of this influence, neither reason nor authority makes manifest, since the influence of the other lower bodies seems sufficiently to suffice. — Therefore, declining wholly to neither part, it seems it must be said that, since the empyrean heaven is the first thing created among bodies, which is the greatest in mass and power: because it is greatest in mass, it locates all bodies13 by encompassing and containing [them]; because [it is] greatest p. 75in power, it vivifies and conserves the rest by its influence. Omitting therefore that influence which it is said to have over human bodies, it can be maintained that it has some effect and some influence over the lower bodies, as the first thing created [influences] over the things following. And the reasons adduced for this are to be granted.

1. 2. To what then is objected concerning the influence of light and heat, it must be said that the influence of light can be twofold: either manifest or hidden. Manifest influence is through a transparent body, especially when it is perceived by sense. Hidden influence is not only through a transparent body but also through an opaque one, just as the power of the stars is in the minerals which lie hidden under the earth. — Or it can be said that there is a mediate and an immediate influence; and it is possible that the influence of the starry heaven is strengthened by the help of the light of the higher heavens, and derives the power received from above and transmits it to these lower things; and it seems to us to be proper to them14, although it is not proper [to them], but also from another. — And through this another [point] is clear, that the power of the lower heavens is not a sufficient cause except by the help of the higher ones.

3. To what is objected concerning conformity, it must be said that the nature of the spirit, which disposes toward life, is conformed to the celestial light itself as to purity; and by this reason it is born to receive; but it is not necessary to be consonant in all [respects].

4. To what is objected, whether toward a nobler effect; it must be said, according to the first opinion, that [it influences] toward a nobler effect, because toward the generation of the spirits which are the disposition for the reception15 of the rational soul. — And if you object that there are no others than those which dispose toward the sensible [soul]: it must be said that, although they are not wholly other according to form, yet they are purer and born to minister to more excellent and nobler powers, according to which reason also the complexion and organization both of the human body and of the brute [body] must be nobler. — Yet it can be maintained that they influence toward the same effects, nor does either of them become superfluous, because the power and influence of the lower heaven is aided by the power of the higher, and the power of the higher operates by means of the power and influence of the lower; therefore neither becomes superfluous, but for these lower things to be conserved and perfected the power of both concurs16.

---

Apparatus Criticus
  1. 1
    Vide Dionys. de Caelest. Hierarch. c. 11, ex quo quaedam invenies tom. 1. pag. 79, nota 5. — Paulo inferius cod. N aut per illam operatur, plures alii codd. cum ed. 1 incongrue aut per quam operatur pro aut operatur.
    See Dionysius, On the Celestial Hierarchy, c. 11, from which you will find some [things] in tom. 1, p. 79, note 5. — A little below codex N [reads] aut per illam operatur, several other codices with ed. 1 incongruously aut per quam operatur for aut operatur.
  2. 2
    Cfr. supra pag. 46, nota 1. — In Vat. sequens propositio sic sonat: ergo si empyreum aliquid est, in aliquo servit huiusmodi.
    Cf. above p. 46, note 1. — In the Vatican edition the following proposition runs thus: therefore if the empyrean is anything, in some respect it serves [a being] of this kind.
  3. 3
    Aristot., de Mundo, c. 7. (c. 6.), recitato consensu mortalium, qui Deo summam regionem mundi tribuit et nos ipsos elevare manus facit sursum inter vota concipienda, ait: Quin etiam quae maxime eximia sunt inter res sensu perceptas eundem illa locum obtinent, ut sidera, ut sol et luna.
    Aristotle, On the World, c. 7 (c. 6), the consensus of mortals being recited, which attributes the highest region of the world to God and makes us ourselves raise [our] hands upward while conceiving [our] prayers, says: Indeed even the things which are most excellent among the things perceived by sense obtain that same place, like the stars, like the sun and moon.
  4. 4
    Non pauci codd. perperam bonum. In fine argumenti cod. cc cum ed. 1 ponit maxime sit influens pro magis sit influens, ubi cod. 1 addit quam alia corpora.
    Not a few codices wrongly [read] bonum ["good"]. At the end of the argument codex cc with ed. 1 puts maxime sit influens ["is most of all influencing"] for magis sit influens ["is more influencing"], where cod. 1 adds quam alia corpora ["than the other bodies"].
  5. 5
    Vat. cum paucis mss. prosequitur quia non est in motu, nec ista corpora inferiora, sicut patet, irradiat.
    The Vatican edition, with a few manuscripts, continues because it is not in motion, nor does it irradiate these lower bodies, as is plain.
  6. 6
    Aristot., III. de Anima, text. 45. (c. 9.). — Aliquanto superius plures codd. cum ed. 1 intra firmamentum pro infra firmamentum.
    Aristotle, III On the Soul, text 45 (c. 9). — Somewhat above, several codices with ed. 1 [read] intra firmamentum ["within the firmament"] for infra firmamentum ["below the firmament"].
  7. 7
    Cod. cc et ed. 1 infima. In fine argumenti cod. bb influentiam habeat pro influere habeat.
    Codex cc and ed. 1 [read] infima ["lowest"]. At the end of the argument codex bb [reads] influentiam habeat ["has an influence"] for influere habeat ["has [the property] to influence"].
  8. 8
    Sufficiat hic adducere Averroem, qui in suo libro de Substantia orbis (c. 1.) ait: Calor vero corporum caelestium largitur vitam vegetabilem, sensibilem et animalem. — Vat. cum nonnullis mss. viri philosophici. Paulo superius codd. cum ed. 1 post quod subiiciunt autem, omissa vel male transposita voce Probatio post ad magis nobilem non potest. Cod. aa non mutat post immo a creatore est pure pro immo est a creatione pura.
    Let it suffice here to adduce Averroes, who in his book On the Substance of the Orb (c. 1) says: But the heat of the celestial bodies bestows vegetable, sensible, and animal life. — The Vatican edition, with some manuscripts, [reads] viri philosophici ["philosophical men"]. A little above the codices with ed. 1, after quod, subjoin autem, the word Probatio being omitted or badly transposed after ad magis nobilem non potest. Codex aa [reads] non mutat [...], immo a creatore est pure for immo est a creatione pura.
  9. 9
    De his cfr. supra d. 1. p. II. a. 1. q. 2. ad 2. 3.
    On these [things] cf. above d. 1, p. II, a. 1, q. 2, ad 2, 3.
  10. 10
    Cod. L conformant.
    Codex L [reads] conformant ["they conform"].
  11. 11
    Ex cod. cc et ed. 1 supplevimus illa, pro quo cod. N eius. Aliquanto superius cod. A secundum ordinationem Conditoris pro secundum ordinem Conditoris.
    From codex cc and ed. 1 we have supplied illa ["that"], for which codex N [reads] eius ["its"]. Somewhat above codex A [reads] secundum ordinationem Conditoris for secundum ordinem Conditoris.
  12. 12
    In cod. aa additur eius. Paulo ante plures codd. ut U V Z consistit pro subsistit.
    In codex aa is added eius ["its"]. A little before, several codices, as U V Z, [read] consistit for subsistit.
  13. 13
    Non pauci codd. cum ed. 1 corporalia.
    Not a few codices, with ed. 1, [read] corporalia ["corporeal [things]"].
  14. 14
    In Vat. deest illorum. Dein nonnulli codd. cum non tantum pro cum tamen non. Melius esset cum tamen non tantum.
    In the Vatican edition illorum ["of them"] is lacking. Then some codices [read] cum non tantum for cum tamen non. It would be better [to read] cum tamen non tantum.
  15. 15
    Cod. T receptionem.
    Codex T [reads] receptionem ["the receiving"].
  16. 16
    Vide Scholion praecedentis quaestionis.
    See the Scholion of the preceding question.
Cite this

St. Bonaventure, Commentarius in II librum Sententiarum, Dist. 2, Part 2, Art. 1, Q. 2, in Opera Omnia (Quaracchi, 1885), tom. II, pp. 73–75.

English translation: Wroot Press, Bonaventure Opera Omnia Translation Project, bonaventure.wrootpress.com/sentences/2/d2/p2-a1-q2. Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0.

Authorities cited here

Aristotle, De anima · Averroes (Ibn Rushd), De substantia orbis · Dionysius the Areopagite (Pseudo-Dionysius), De caelesti hierarchia