← Back to Distinction 3

Dist. 3, Part 2, Art. 2, Q. 1

Book III: On the Incarnation of the Word · Distinction 3

Contents
  1. Article II. On the conveying of Christ's flesh.
  2. Question I. Whether Christ's flesh in Abraham and the other Fathers was distinct in quality from the flesh of other men.
  3. Conclusio
Textus Latinus
English Translation
p. 85

Articulus II. De carnis Christi traductione.

Consequenter quaeritur de carnis Christi traductione. Et circa hoc quaeruntur duo.

Primo quaeritur, utrum caro Christi fuerit in primis parentibus secundum qualitatem puritatis1 vel inquinationis.

Secundo quaeritur, utrum aliter fuerit quam secundum legem propagationis.

Quaestio I. Utrum caro Christi in Abraham et aliis Patribus distincta fuerit secundum qualitatem a carne aliorum hominum.

Circa primum sic proceditur et ostenditur, quod caro Christi in Abraham et aliis Patribus distincta fuerit secundum qualitatem a carne aliorum filiorum.

1. Septimo Sapientiae2: Nihil coinquinatum in illam incurrit: ergo si caro Christi unita est Filio Dei, qui est Dei virtus et Dei sapientia, videtur, quod nunquam fuerit inquinata; sed caro aliorum in parentibus inquinata fuit: ergo videtur, quod aliter fuerit caro Christi in Abraham quam aliorum.

2. Item, in Christo debuit esse maxima puritas; sed magis purum est quod nunquam fuit inquinatum, quam illud quod aliquando inquinatum fuit: ergo videtur, quod caro Christi nec in se nec in parentibus subiacuerit foeditati corruptionis3: igitur a carne aliorum hominum distincta fuit qualitative.

3. Item, alterius qualitatis est medicina et illud quod curatur per medicinam; sed caro Christi fuit in lumbis Patrum sicut medicina, sicut dicit Augustinus decimo super Genesim ad litteram4, caro vero aliorum hominum sicut indigens medicina: ergo videtur, quod habuerit qualitatem aliam et aliam.

4. Item, quod totaliter corruptum est non est possibile ad curationem: si ergo Adam fuit possibilis ad curationem, aliqua particula remansit in eo incorrupta. Sed de illa particula, quae5 sine corruptione erat, maxime decebat generari carnem, quae esset sine originali macula: ergo videtur etc.

Sed contra: 1. Augustinus decimo super Genesim ad litteram6: « Eadem namque caro non Abrahae tantum, sed ipsius primi terrenique hominis simul habuit vulnus praevaricationis et medicamentum vulneris » : ergo si medicamentum vulneris spectat ad Christum, vulnus praevaricationis spectat ad alios, eadem igitur fuit caro Christi in primis parentibus cum carne aliorum: ergo non fuit distincta ab aliis.

2. Item, Magister in principio huius distinctionis7 loquens de carne Christi: « Credi oportet iuxta sanctorum Doctorum convenientiam, ipsam prius fuisse peccato obnoxiam, sicut fuit reliqua Virginis caro » : restat igitur idem quod prius, quod non fuerit distincta ab aliis.

3. Item, quidquid lege corruptionis traducitur, corruptum est; sed tota caro Isaac, quae fuit traducta ab Abraham, fuit corrupta: aut igitur8 caro Christi non fuit traducta ab Abraham in Isaac, aut si traducta fuit, ab aliis hominibus distincta non fuit.

4. Item, aut caro Christi fuit similis carni Abrahae reliquae, aut non. Si similis, habeo propositum; si dissimilis: ergo non videtur, quod talis caro competeret ad redemptionem humani generis9. Si ergo hoc est falsum et inconveniens, restat ergo, quod caro Christi a carne aliorum hominum non fuerit distincta.

5. Item, distinctio secundum oppositas qualitates praesupponit distinctionem secundum substantiam, quia oppositae qualitates non possunt esse in eodem et secundum idem10; sed caro filiorum in primis parentibus non potuit habere distinctionem secundum substantiam, quia non esset tot atomos invenire in corpore Adae, quot inde filii procreati sunt: ergo si caro Christi in primis parentibus non p. 86 potuit distingui a carne aliorum secundum substantiam, videtur etc.

6. Item, si transfundebatur caro munda, aut corruptibilis, aut incorruptibilis. Si incorruptibilis: ergo corpus Christi debuit esse impassibile; quod falsum est. Si corruptibilis: ergo videtur, quod poterat transmutari in carnem reliquam et augeri ab alia: ergo et alia poterat pari ratione transmutari in aliis11: igitur aut caro illa fuit consumta, antequam perveniret ad Christum, aut fuit adeo multiplicata, ut possent inde mille corpora formari. Sed hoc est falsum: ergo etc.

Conclusio

Caro Christi in lumbis parentum, in quibus fuit materialiter, a carne aliorum hominum non fuit distincta qualitative vel formaliter.

Respondeo: Ad praedictorum intelligentiam est notandum, quod circa hanc quaestionem fuit quaedam positio erronea quorundam dicentium, quod caro Christi non tantum distinctionem habuit a carne aliorum hominum, cum fuit unita animae Christi12, sed etiam cum fuit in lumbis hominis primi. Dicebant enim, quod quia Adam reparabiliter peccavit, in peccato non permisit Deus totum corrumpi; et ideo remansit in eius semine aliqua portio incorrupta, ut per illam fieret medicamentum carni reliquae; et ex illa portiuncula13 dicunt carnem Christi formatam, quam dicunt esse generis humani medicinam. Hanc autem particulam transmisit Adam ad Noe, et Noe ad Abraham, et Abraham ad David, et David usque ad Virginem, de qua natus est Christus. — Haec autem positio, etsi habere videatur probabilitatem in superficie, intrinsecus errorem14 continet; pro eo quod non solum est contra Sanctorum dicta veridica, sed etiam contra verae fidei documenta. Sanctorum auctoritatibus repugnat: quia Damascenus, doctor Graecus, et Augustinus, praecipuus doctor Latinus, in hoc consentiunt, quod caro Christi ante unionem cum Verbo indistincta erat a reliqua Virginis carne. Damascenus15 dicit, quod « de purissimis Virginis sanguinibus fuerit formata » ; Augustinus dicit, quod « assumserit primitiam nostrae massae ». — Et hoc quidem necessarium est ponere, quia non fuisset necessaria Virginis sanctificatio ad hoc, quod formaretur caro Christi sine omni peccato. — Non esset etiam Christus vere de semine David et Abrahae, sed solum Adae; quoniam, si praedicto modo illa16 particula descendisset, ad nullum aliorum pertineret nisi sicut deferens, quemadmodum aqua comparatur ad canalem. — Non etiam esset in tali carne verae passibilitatis assumtio nec nostrae infirmitatis vera reparatio, quia non de natura lapsa fabricasset sibi carnem, sed potius de instituta. — Quae omnia inconvenientia sunt et fidei sanae adversantia. Et ideo praedicta positio tanquam erronea est respuenda, sicut Magister bene innuit in littera17, et Magister Hugo in libro de Sacramentis.

Planum est igitur secundum doctrinam catholicam, carnem Christi in lumbis parentum, in quibus fuit materialiter, a carne aliorum hominum non fuisse distinctam qualitative, vel formaliter, quamvis, postquam unita est Verbo, distinctionem habeat, pro eo quod non est caro peccati, sed similis peccatrici. Et pro tanto dicit Augustinus18, quod « caro Christi venerit de altitudine humanae naturae », non quod in primis parentibus sine pollutione fuerit, sed quia sic purificata est et mundata in sua assumtione, quod similis fuit carni in statu innocentiae. Propter quod dicitur a Boethio19 « de omni statu aliquid accepisse », sicut infra melius manifestabip. 87tur. — Unde rationes, quae ad hanc partem inducuntur, sunt concedendae.

Ad 1. Ad illud vero quod primo obiicitur in contrarium de Sapientiae septimo, quod nihil inquinatum in illam incurrit; dicendum, quod verum est; hoc enim intelligitur de Sapientia divina20 secundum divinam naturam, quae nullo modo foedatur ex aliqua creatura; verumtamen, si etiam intelligatur secundum humanam naturam, adhuc non habet instantiam, quia caro Christi, ex quo fuit unita Verbo Dei, sancta fuit et immaculata. Sed ex hoc non sequitur, quod immaculata fuisset in primis parentibus, pro eo quod, quamvis in lumbis parentum esset unibilis, erat tamen in dispositione remota.

Ad 2. Ad illud quod obiicitur, quod maxima puritas debet esse in carne Christi; dicendum, quod verum est, secundum quod competit ad reparationem humani generis. Sic autem intelligendo, non potest maior puritas cogitari, quam quod de massa peccatrice formetur caro omnino immunis a peccato; et sic factum est in carne unita Verbo, operante Spiritu sancto. Quodsi intelligatur caro illa nunquam in se, vel in parentibus fuisse obnoxia21; non sic cogitatur, qualiter nostrae reparationi fuerit apta; et ideo non cogitatur, qualiter et sicut debet, sed potius assignatur, qualiter non debet.

Ad 3. Ad illud quod obiicitur, quod caro Christi est medicina; dicendum, quod verum est pro tempore, quo medicina est; medicina autem est pro eo tempore, quo a Verbo22 assumta est; et sic alterius qualitatis est quam aliorum hominum. Pro eo autem tempore, quo fuit ante assumtionem, non erat medicina, nisi materialiter loquendo. Secundum illud tempus non oportet formaliter distingui ab alia carne, pro eo quod ex eodem principio materiali potest formari sanum et aegrum. Cibus enim eiusdem generis in sano convertitur in carnem sanam et in leproso in carnem corruptam.

Ad 4. Ad illud quod obiicitur, quod si totus esset corruptus, iam non esset medicabilis eius morbus: dicendum, quod illud argumentum dupliciter deficit. Primo, quia, etsi homo totus corruptus esset, non sequitur, quod incurabilis esset, nisi illa corruptio ei inseparabiliter adhaereret. Praeterea, etsi totus homo corruptus esset quantum ad ea quae erant in se, non tamen corruptum esset totum genus humanum, quod fabricatum est ex illa hominis carne; sed illud solum, quod processit secundum legem concupiscentiae. Et quoniam caro Christi in Virgine fabricata est praeter legem concupiscentiae a Spiritu sancto sanctificante23, hinc est, quod caruit corruptione et rationem tenuit medicinae a sua primaria formatione.

Article II. On the conveying of Christ's flesh.

Next it is asked about the conveying of Christ's flesh. And concerning this two things are asked.

First it is asked whether Christ's flesh was in the first parents according to a quality of purity1 or of defilement.

Second it is asked whether it was otherwise than according to the law of propagation.

Question I. Whether Christ's flesh in Abraham and the other Fathers was distinct in quality from the flesh of other men.

Concerning the first one proceeds thus, and it is shown that Christ's flesh in Abraham and the other Fathers was distinct in quality from the flesh of the other sons.

1. Wisdom 72: Nothing defiled enters into her: therefore if Christ's flesh was united to the Son of God, who is the power of God and the wisdom of God, it seems that it was never defiled; but the flesh of others was defiled in the parents: therefore it seems that Christ's flesh was otherwise in Abraham than that of others.

2. Likewise, in Christ there ought to have been the greatest purity; but that which was never defiled is more pure than that which was at some time defiled: therefore it seems that Christ's flesh neither in itself nor in the parents was subject to the foulness of corruption3: therefore it was distinct in quality from the flesh of other men.

3. Likewise, medicine and that which is cured by medicine are of a different quality; but Christ's flesh was in the loins of the Fathers as medicine, as Augustine says in the tenth book On Genesis according to the Letter4, whereas the flesh of other men was as something needing medicine: therefore it seems that it had one quality and another.

4. Likewise, that which is totally corrupted is not capable of being cured: therefore if Adam was capable of being cured, some particle remained in him uncorrupted. But from that particle, which5 was without corruption, it was most fitting that flesh be generated which should be without original stain: therefore it seems so, etc.

Sed contra: 1. Augustine in the tenth book On Genesis according to the Letter6: « For the same flesh, not of Abraham only, but of the first earthly man himself, had at once the wound of transgression and the medicament of the wound » : therefore if the medicament of the wound pertains to Christ, the wound of transgression pertains to others, therefore the flesh of Christ in the first parents was the same as the flesh of others: therefore it was not distinct from others.

2. Likewise, the Master at the beginning of this distinction7, speaking of Christ's flesh: « It must be believed, according to the agreement of the holy Doctors, that it was first subject to sin, just as was the rest of the Virgin's flesh » : it therefore remains as before, that it was not distinct from others.

3. Likewise, whatever is conveyed by the law of corruption is corrupted; but the whole flesh of Isaac, which was conveyed from Abraham, was corrupted: therefore either8 Christ's flesh was not conveyed from Abraham into Isaac, or, if it was conveyed, it was not distinct from other men.

4. Likewise, either Christ's flesh was like the rest of the flesh of Abraham, or not. If like, I have my point; if unlike: then it does not seem that such flesh was suited to the redemption of the human race9. If therefore this is false and unfitting, it remains, then, that Christ's flesh was not distinct from the flesh of other men.

5. Likewise, distinction according to opposite qualities presupposes distinction according to substance, because opposite qualities cannot be in the same thing and according to the same10; but the flesh of the sons in the first parents could not have a distinction according to substance, because there would not be found as many atoms in the body of Adam as there were sons procreated from it: therefore if Christ's flesh in the first parents could not be distinguished from the flesh of others according to substance, it seems so, etc.

6. Likewise, if pure flesh was transfused, it was either corruptible or incorruptible. If incorruptible: then Christ's body ought to have been impassible; which is false. If corruptible: then it seems that it could be transmuted into the rest of the flesh and increased by other flesh: therefore other flesh too could by parity of reasoning be transmuted into others11: therefore either that flesh was consumed before it reached Christ, or it was so multiplied that a thousand bodies could be formed from it. But this is false: therefore, etc.

Conclusio

Christ's flesh, in the loins of the parents in which it was materially, was not distinct in quality or in form from the flesh of other men.

Respondeo: For the understanding of the foregoing it must be noted that concerning this question there was a certain erroneous position of certain men saying that Christ's flesh had a distinction from the flesh of other men not only when it was united to Christ's soul12, but even when it was in the loins of the first man. For they said that, because Adam sinned reparably, in his sin God did not permit the whole to be corrupted; and so there remained in his seed some uncorrupted portion, that through it there might be a medicament for the rest of the flesh; and from that little portion13 they say Christ's flesh was formed, which they say is the medicine of the human race. And this particle Adam transmitted to Noah, and Noah to Abraham, and Abraham to David, and David down to the Virgin, of whom Christ was born. — But this position, although it may seem to have probability on the surface, inwardly contains error14; because it is not only against the truthful sayings of the Saints, but also against the documents of the true faith. It is repugnant to the authorities of the Saints: because Damascene, the Greek doctor, and Augustine, the chief Latin doctor, agree in this, that Christ's flesh before its union with the Word was undistinguished from the rest of the Virgin's flesh. Damascene15 says that « it was formed from the most pure blood of the Virgin » ; Augustine says that « he assumed the first-fruits of our mass ». — And this indeed it is necessary to hold, because the Virgin's sanctification would not have been necessary in order that Christ's flesh be formed without any sin. — Nor would Christ truly be of the seed of David and Abraham, but only of Adam; since, if in the aforesaid way that16 particle had descended, it would pertain to none of the others except as a conduit, just as water is compared to a channel. — Nor would there be in such flesh a true assumption of passibility nor a true repair of our infirmity, because he would not have fashioned flesh for himself from fallen nature, but rather from constituted nature. — All which things are unfitting and adverse to sound faith. And therefore the aforesaid position must be rejected as erroneous, just as the Master well intimates in the text17, and Master Hugh in the book On the Sacraments.

It is therefore plain according to Catholic doctrine that Christ's flesh, in the loins of the parents in which it was materially, was not distinct in quality, or in form, from the flesh of other men, although, after it was united to the Word, it has a distinction, in that it is not the flesh of sin, but like sinful flesh. And for this reason Augustine says18 that « Christ's flesh came from the height of human nature », not that in the first parents it was without pollution, but because it was so purified and cleansed in its assumption that it was like the flesh in the state of innocence. On account of which it is said by Boethius19 to have « received something of every state », as will be better shown belowp. 87. — Hence the reasonings which are brought forward for this part are to be granted.

Ad 1. To that which is first objected to the contrary from Wisdom 7, that nothing defiled enters into her; it must be said that it is true; for this is understood of the divine Wisdom20 according to the divine nature, which is in no way defiled by any creature; nevertheless, if it be also understood according to the human nature, it still has no instance against us, because Christ's flesh, from the time it was united to the Word of God, was holy and immaculate. But from this it does not follow that it was immaculate in the first parents, because, although in the loins of the parents it was unitable, it was nevertheless in a remote disposition.

Ad 2. To that which is objected, that the greatest purity ought to be in Christ's flesh; it must be said that it is true, according as it is suited to the repair of the human race. Understanding it thus, no greater purity can be conceived than that from the sinful mass flesh be formed altogether free from sin; and so it was done in the flesh united to the Word, by the working of the Holy Spirit. But if that flesh be understood never to have been subject to sin in itself or in the parents21; it is not thereby conceived how it was apt for our repair; and therefore it is not conceived how and as it ought, but rather it is assigned how it ought not.

Ad 3. To that which is objected, that Christ's flesh is medicine; it must be said that it is true for the time at which it is medicine; and it is medicine for the time at which it was assumed by the Word22; and thus it is of a different quality than that of other men. But for the time at which it was before the assumption, it was not medicine, except materially speaking. According to that time it need not be formally distinguished from other flesh, because from the same material principle there can be formed what is healthy and what is sick. For food of the same kind is converted in a healthy man into healthy flesh and in a leper into corrupt flesh.

Ad 4. To that which is objected, that if the whole were corrupted, his disease would no longer be curable: it must be said that that argument fails in two ways. First, because, even if the whole man were corrupted, it does not follow that he was incurable, unless that corruption inseparably adhered to him. Furthermore, even if the whole man were corrupted as to the things that were in him, yet the whole human race, which is fashioned from that man's flesh, would not be corrupted; but only that which proceeded according to the law of concupiscence. And since Christ's flesh was fashioned in the Virgin apart from the law of concupiscence by the sanctifying Holy Spirit23, hence it is that it lacked corruption and held the account of medicine from its primary formation.

Scholion

I. Haec et seq. quaestio etiam a S. Thoma (S. III. q. 31. a. 6. 7; cfr. Comment. hic q. 1. a. 1. 2.) duabus quaestionibus, sed paulo aliter positis, tractatur, quarum prima est, utrum corpus Christi in antiquis Patribus fuerit secundum aliquid signatum; secunda, utrum caro Christi in Patribus fuerit peccato obnoxia. Communiter Scholastici ut erroneum reprobant figmentum illud, a nonnullis antiquis et etiam recentioribus sparsum, quod in Adam in peccatum lapso aliqua pars carnis a peccato non sit infecta et per subsequentes generationes incorrupte traducta, quod hic in corp. magis declaratur. Plura de hac opinione tradit Hugo a S. Vict., II. de Sacram. p. I. c. 8.

II. Exceptis S. Thoma (locc. citt.), B. Alberto et Aegidio R., alii mox citati hanc et seq. q. unica quaestione absolvunt: Alex. Hal., S. p. III. q. 9. m. 3. a. 4. — Scot., hic q. 2; II. Report. d. 33. q. unica n. 11. — B. Albert., hic a. 1. 27. — Petr. a Tar., hic q. 2. a. 1. — Richard. a Med., hic a. 3. q. 1. — Aegid. R., hic q. 4. a. 1. dub. lat. 2. — Dionys. Carth., hic q. 5. — Biel, hic q. 2.

---

Scholion

I. This and the following question is also treated by St. Thomas (Summa III q. 31 a. 6, 7; cf. Commentary here q. 1 a. 1, 2) in two questions, but posed somewhat differently, of which the first is whether the body of Christ in the ancient Fathers was according to something signed; the second, whether Christ's flesh in the Fathers was subject to sin. The Scholastics commonly reprove as erroneous that figment, scattered abroad by certain ancients and also by more recent writers, that in Adam, fallen into sin, some part of the flesh was not infected by sin and was conveyed uncorrupted through the subsequent generations — which is here more fully explained in the body. Hugh of St. Victor relates more on this opinion, On the Sacraments II p. I c. 8.

II. Excepting St. Thomas (locc. cit.), Bl. Albert, and Giles of Rome, the others cited below settle this and the following question in a single question: Alexander of Hales, Summa p. III q. 9 m. 3 a. 4. — Scotus, here q. 2; Reportata II d. 33 q. unica n. 11. — Bl. Albert, here a. 1, 27. — Peter of Tarentaise, here q. 2 a. 1. — Richard of Mediavilla, here a. 3 q. 1. — Giles of Rome, here q. 4 a. 1 dub. lat. 2. — Denis the Carthusian, here q. 5. — Biel, here q. 2.

---

Apparatus Criticus
  1. 1
    Codd. A F H N T U V Z et edd. 1, 2 omittunt puritatis.
    Codices A F H N T U V Z and editions 1, 2 omit puritatis (of purity).
  2. 2
    Vers. 25, ubi Vulgata cum edd. inquinatum pro coinquinatum. Verba deinde Dei virtus et Dei sapientia inveniuntur I. Cor. 1, 24. — Paulo superius post aliorum filiorum Vat. cum cod. A subiungit et quod sic videtur [Vat. adhuc addit secundum illud]. Pro unita codd. U W X iuncta.
    Verse 25, where the Vulgate with the editions reads inquinatum for coinquinatum. The words then the power of God and the wisdom of God are found in 1 Cor. 1, 24. — A little above, after aliorum filiorum (of the other sons), the Vatican edition with codex A subjoins et quod sic videtur (and that it seems so) [the Vatican still adds secundum illud (according to that)]. For unita (united) codices U W X read iuncta (joined).
  3. 3
    Codd. U X carnis, Vat. corruptionis vel carnis.
    Codices U X read carnis (of flesh), the Vatican edition corruptionis vel carnis (of corruption or of flesh).
  4. 4
    Cap. 20. n. 36. Verba ipsa videsis supra a. 1. q. 1. in corp. circa finem et q. 2. fundam. 1.
    Chapter 20, n. 36. The very words you may see above, a. 1 q. 1 in the body near the end, and q. 2 fundamentum 1.
  5. 5
    Edd. loco erat, quod omittunt, hic exhibent remansit.
    The editions, in place of erat (was), which they omit, here exhibit remansit (remained).
  6. 6
    Cap. 20. n. 36.
    Chapter 20, n. 36.
  7. 7
    Cap. 1.
    Chapter 1.
  8. 8
    Pro aut igitur cod. V et edd. 1, 2 ergo similiter, Vat. ergo simul. Immediate ante pro quae fuit traducta ab Abraham cod. T quia fuit traducta in Abraham. Lectionem in Abraham habent etiam codd. G H L N U V aa cc. Edd. 1, 2 legunt tota caro Abraham, quae fuit traducta in Isaac.
    For aut igitur (therefore either) codex V and editions 1, 2 read ergo similiter (therefore likewise), the Vatican edition ergo simul (therefore together). Immediately before, for quae fuit traducta ab Abraham (which was conveyed from Abraham) codex T reads quia fuit traducta in Abraham (because it was conveyed in Abraham). The reading in Abraham is also had by codices G H L N U V aa cc. Editions 1, 2 read tota caro Abraham, quae fuit traducta in Isaac (the whole flesh of Abraham, which was conveyed into Isaac).
  9. 9
    Vide infra d. 12. a. 1. q. 1.
    See below, d. 12 a. 1 q. 1.
  10. 10
    Aristot. de Praedicam. c. de Oppositis, et II. Periherm. c. 1. (c. 14.): Simul autem non contingit eidem inesse contraria. — De propos. seq. cfr. II. Sent. d. XXX. lit. Magistri, c. 13. — Mox pro filiorum cod. X substituit aliorum, in edd. legitur aliorum filiorum.
    Aristotle, Categories, chapter On Opposites, and On Interpretation II c. 1 (c. 14): But contraries do not happen to be in the same thing at the same time. — On the following proposition cf. Sentences II d. 30, text of the Master, c. 13. — Then for filiorum (of the sons) codex X substitutes aliorum (of the others); in the editions is read aliorum filiorum (of the other sons).
  11. 11
    Hanc ultimam conclusionem, quae in Vat. desideratur, ex codd. C D G L N P Q S U W X Y bb et edd. 1, 2 restituimus, memoratis codd. aliquantulum tantum inter se dissentientibus. Etenim pro et alia codd. N U habent et illa, cod. C alii, cod. S in aliam; pro poterat plures codd. poterant; pro in aliis cod. C in ipsam, cod. S in carnem. Paulo ante pro augeri codd. C D G L W X substituunt assumi, edd. verbo augeri praefigunt assumi vel. Circa finem arg. pro corpora cod. N exhibet homines.
    This last conclusion, which is wanting in the Vatican edition, we have restored from codices C D G L N P Q S U W X Y bb and editions 1, 2, the said codices differing only a little among themselves. For et alia (and other) codices N U have et illa (and that), codex C alii (others), codex S in aliam (into another); for poterat (could) several codices read poterant (they could); for in aliis (into others) codex C in ipsam (into it), codex S in carnem (into flesh). A little before, for augeri (be increased) codices C D G L W X substitute assumi (be assumed); the editions prefix to the word augeri the phrase assumi vel (be assumed or). Near the end of the argument, for corpora (bodies) codex N exhibits homines (men).
  12. 12
    Cod. F cum fuit Verbo unita anima Christi.
    Codex F reads cum fuit Verbo unita anima Christi (when Christ's soul was united to the Word).
  13. 13
    Cod. A particula. Mox pro particulam Vat. portiunculam.
    Codex A reads particula. Then for particulam (particle) the Vatican edition reads portiunculam (little portion).
  14. 14
    Edd. voci errorem praemittunt tamen falsum et, ac deinde post dicta omittunt veridica. Mox pro verae fidei codd. M O substituunt verbi Dei, cod. Y nostrae fidei.
    The editions prefix to the word errorem (error) the phrase tamen falsum et (yet false and), and then after dicta (sayings) omit veridica (truthful). Then for verae fidei (of the true faith) codices M O substitute verbi Dei (of the Word of God), codex Y nostrae fidei (of our faith).
  15. 15
    Libr. III. de Fide orthod. c. 2. et IV. c. 14. Cfr. hic lit. Magistri, c. 1. Eodem loco, c. 3, habetur etiam dictum Augustini et asseritur, Christum primitias nostrae massae assumsisse, « quia non carnem peccati, sed similitudinem peccati accepit ». Quod August. etiam X. de Gen. ad lit. c. 18. n. 32. docet, et Serm. 27. (alias 20. de Verbis Apostoli) c. 2. n. 2, nec non Serm. 134. (alias 28. de Verbis Domini) c. 3. n. 4, ac Serm. 155. (alias 6. de Verbis Apostoli) c. 7. n. 7. etc.; sicut et in libris, quos scripsit contra Iulianum Pelagian., cuius doctrinam castigans dicit: Manichaeus haereticus carnem negat Christi; Pelagianus haereticus carnem peccati carni coaequare vult Christi; Christianus catholicus similitudinem carnis peccati discernit a carne peccati, ne blasphemet carnem Christi (IV. oper. imperf. contra Iulian. c. 81.). Similia dicit Enarrat. in Ps. 64. n. 5: « Tulit inde primitias ex utero virginali » ; et expressissime in Ps. 70. serm. 2. n. 10: « Caro factus: unde caro? Ex Maria Virgine. Unde Maria Virgo? Ex Adam. Ergo ex illo primo captivo et caro in Christo de massa captivitatis ». Damasc., III. de Fide orthod. c. 2, carnem ex purissimis Virginis sanguinibus formatam et anima rationali animatam vocat primitias nostrae conspersionis, cuius locutionis explicationem infra habebis, dub. 2. — Pro primitiam edd. substituunt primitiva, et paulo inferius post quia bene interiiciunt alias.
    On the Orthodox Faith book III c. 2 and IV c. 14. Cf. here the text of the Master, c. 1. In the same place, c. 3, is also had the saying of Augustine and it is asserted that Christ assumed the first-fruits of our mass, « because he received not the flesh of sin, but the likeness of sin ». Which Augustine also teaches in On Genesis according to the Letter X c. 18 n. 32, and Sermon 27 (otherwise 20, On the Words of the Apostle) c. 2 n. 2, and also Sermon 134 (otherwise 28, On the Words of the Lord) c. 3 n. 4, and Sermon 155 (otherwise 6, On the Words of the Apostle) c. 7 n. 7, etc.; as also in the books he wrote against Julian the Pelagian, whose doctrine, correcting it, he says: The Manichaean heretic denies the flesh of Christ; the Pelagian heretic wishes to equate the flesh of sin with the flesh of Christ; the Catholic Christian distinguishes the likeness of the flesh of sin from the flesh of sin, lest he blaspheme the flesh of Christ (Imperfect Work against Julian IV c. 81). He says similar things in Enarratio on Psalm 64 n. 5: « He took thence first-fruits from the virginal womb » ; and most expressly in Psalm 70 sermon 2 n. 10: « Made flesh: whence the flesh? From Mary the Virgin. Whence Mary the Virgin? From Adam. Therefore from that first captive, and the flesh in Christ is from the mass of captivity ». Damascene, On the Orthodox Faith III c. 2, calls the flesh formed from the most pure blood of the Virgin and animated by a rational soul the first-fruits of our mass, the explanation of which expression you will have below, dub. 2. — For primitiam the editions substitute primitiva, and a little below after quia (because) they aptly insert alias (otherwise).
  16. 16
    Edd. ab illa, et mox verbo deferens praefigunt ad.
    The editions read ab illa (from that), and presently prefix ad to the word deferens (conduit).
  17. 17
    Hic c. 3. seq. Hugo II. de Sacram. p. I. c. 8. Cfr. eius Quaest. in Epist. ad Hebr. q. 69. — Pro respuenda codd. H N U V reputanda.
    Here c. 3 seq. Hugh, On the Sacraments II p. I c. 8. Cf. his Questions on the Epistle to the Hebrews q. 69. — For respuenda (to be rejected) codices H N U V read reputanda (to be reckoned).
  18. 18
    In Glossa ordinaria super illud Ioan. 3: Qui desursum est super omnes est haec verba habentur, et infra in lit. Magistri, d. XVI. in fine, Augustino attribuuntur. — Pro venerit codd. N U venit.
    In the Ordinary Gloss on that text of John 3: He who is from above is above all these words are had, and below in the text of the Master, d. 16 at the end, they are attributed to Augustine. — For venerit (came) codices N U read venit (comes).
  19. 19
    De Una Persona et duabus naturis, c. 8. Cfr. infra d. 15. et 16, et praesertim dub. 4. huius ultimae dist.
    On the One Person and the Two Natures, c. 8. Cf. below d. 15 and 16, and especially dub. 4 of this last distinction.
  20. 20
    Codd. A F H N T U V Z et edd. 1, 2 omittunt divina.
    Codices A F H N T U V Z and editions 1, 2 omit divina (divine).
  21. 21
    Supple cum codd. M O peccato. Paulo superius pro operante codd. U aa cooperante, ac subinde pro Quodsi codd. D V et edd. 1, 2 quia si. Mox pro reparationi multi codd. reparationis, edd. redemptioni; nostram lectionem defendunt codd. A K P Q U X (bb a secunda manu). In fine solut. pro assignatur codd. A H U W substituunt figuratur, codd. F T V bb et edd. 1, 2 significatur (vel signatur) cod. Z cogitatur; cod. K omittit assignatur, voculae potius praemisso ita.
    Supply with codices M O peccato (to sin). A little above, for operante (working) codices U aa read cooperante (cooperating), and thereupon for Quodsi (but if) codices D V and editions 1, 2 quia si (because if). Then for reparationi (for repair) many codices read reparationis (of repair), the editions redemptioni (for redemption); codices A K P Q U X (bb by a second hand) defend our reading. At the end of the solution, for assignatur (is assigned) codices A H U W substitute figuratur (is figured), codices F T V bb and editions 1, 2 significatur (or signatur, is signified), codex Z cogitatur (is conceived); codex K omits assignatur, the little word potius (rather) being prefixed with ita (so).
  22. 22
    Codd. F G H L N aa omittunt a Verbo.
    Codices F G H L N aa omit a Verbo (by the Word).
  23. 23
    Pro sanctificante, quod abest ab edd., codd. W X Y cooperante vel sanctificante.
    For sanctificante (sanctifying), which is absent from the editions, codices W X Y read cooperante vel sanctificante (cooperating or sanctifying).
Cite this

St. Bonaventure, Commentarius in III librum Sententiarum, Dist. 3, Part 2, Art. 2, Q. 1, in Opera Omnia (Quaracchi, 1887), tom. III, pp. 85–87.

English translation: Wroot Press, Bonaventure Opera Omnia Translation Project, bonaventure.wrootpress.com/sentences/3/d3/p2-a2-q1. Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0.

Authorities cited here

Aristotle, Categoriae (Praedicamenta), De interpretatione (Perihermeneias) · Augustine of Hippo, Contra Iulianum, De Genesi ad litteram (3), Enarrationes in Psalmos (2), Sermones (3) · Boethius, Contra Eutychen et Nestorium (De duabus naturis) · Hugh of St. Victor, De sacramentis christianae fidei · John of Damascus, De fide orthodoxa · The Gloss (Glossa ordinaria / interlinearis), Glossa ordinaria

Cited by

8 places in the Opera Omnia citethis question. Derived from Quaracchi’s own apparatus, never tagged by hand.

4 further references address the article or printed page this question belongs to, rather than the question itself.