← Back to Capitulum IX

Cap. 9, Vers. 35-41

Commentarius in Evangelium S. Ioannis · Capitulum IX

Textus Latinus
English Translation
p. 380

In tertia parte describitur spiritualis caeci illuminatio.

46. Audivit Iesus. Haec est tertia pars capituli, in qua, iam descripta mirabili caeci illuminatione et Iudaeorum disceptatione, tertio introducitur de spirituali illius illuminatione. Hanc autem describit Evangelista hoc ordine: primo enim notatur ipsius caeci despecti vocatio benigna; secundo, consentientis illuminatio interna; tertio vero innuitur ipsorum Iudaeorum superborum excaecatio iusta.

(Vers. 35.). Primo ergo insinuatur caeci abiecti vocatio benigna. Eiecerunt enim eum Pharisaei, et Dominus suscepit; propter quod dicit: Audivit Iesus, quia eiecerunt eum foras; per se sciebat, sed nihilominus est ei relatum. Et cum invenisset eum Iesus, non casu, sed studio suscipiendi; Lucae decimo quinto9: « Accendit lucernam et quaerit diligenter, donec inveniat »; dixit ei: Tu credis in Filium Dei? Quaerendo excitat et excitando vocat, ut abiectum suscipiat, secundum illud Psalmi10: « Pater meus et mater mea dereliquerunt me, Dominus autem assumsit me »; Ieremiae quadragesimo nono: « Relinque pupillos tuos, et ego vivere te faciam ».

47. (Vers. 36.). Respondit ille et dixit. Tangitur hic secundum, scilicet consentientis instructio vel illuminatio interna. Consensit enim caecus in fidem; unde dixit: Quis est, Domine, ut credam in eum? Quasi dicat: paratus sum credere; unde Chrysostomus11: « Verbum inquirentis est et desiderantis »; ideo instruitur. Propterea:

48. (Vers. 37.). Dixit12 ei Iesus: Et vidisti eum, et qui loquitur tecum, ipse est. Vidisti, per p. 381 miraculosam operationem; loquitur tecum, per mirabilem instructionem; supra octavo1: « Ego principium, qui et loquor vobis ». Simili modo instruxit Dominus Samaritanam supra quarto: « Ego sum, qui loquor tecum ». Et quia « corde creditur ad iustitiam, ore autem confessio fit ad salutem »; ideo sequitur vera caeci illuminati confessio; et confessus est fidem suam verbo, dicens:

49. (Vers. 38.). Credo2, Domine; et devotionis obsequio, unde: Et procidens adoravit eum, tanquam Deum, qui solus latria est adorandus; unde respondit Dominus diabolo Matthaei quarto: « Dominum Deum tuum adorabis et illi soli servies »; Deuteronomii sexto: « Dominum Deum tuum timebis et illi soli servies ».

50. (Vers. 39.). Et dixit ei3 Iesus. Tangitur hic tertium, scilicet Iudaeorum excaecatio iusta, quam Dominus manifestat caeco, ad quam etiam manifestandam ipsum corporaliter illuminavit. Propterea dicit: In iudicium ego veni in hunc mundum, ut qui non vident videant, et qui vident caeci fiant. In iudicium, scilicet discretionis, ut qui vident, id est, se videre reputant, sicut Iudaei, caeci fiant. De hoc iudicio dicitur ad Romanos undecimo4: « Nolo vos ignorare, fratres, ut non sitis vobismetipsis sapientes, quia caecitas ex parte contigit in Israel, donec plenitudo gentium intraret »; et iterum ad Romanos nono: « Gentes, quae non sectabantur iustitiam, apprehenderunt iustitiam; Israel vero, sectando legem iustitiae, in legem iustitiae non pervenit ». Et quod illud iudicium iustum sit, patet ex inquisitione Pharisaeorum et responsione Domini, in qua innuitur malitia et pertinacia Iudaeorum; quia, cum viderent, noluerunt credere et intelligere: et ideo iudicio Dei et suo peccato sunt excaecati5; ideo dicit:

51. (Vers. 40.). Audierunt6 quidam ex Pharisaeis, qui erant cum ipso, id est, praesentes aderant; et dixerunt: Nunquid et nos caeci sumus? Indignabantur verbo Domini, quia credebant, propter se fuisse dictum, quia se sapientes reputabant: et ex hoc ipso ostendit Dominus divinum iudicium, quod iuste sunt excaecati; propter quod:

52. (Vers. 41.). Dixit eis Iesus: Si caeci essetis, non haberetis peccatum; quia tunc vos Dominus illuminaret; unde primae ad Corinthios tertio7: « Si quis videtur inter vos sapiens esse in hoc saeculo, stultus fiat, ut sit sapiens ». Nunc autem dicitis: Quia videmus, et vos sapientes reputatis; peccatum vestrum manet, scilicet infidelitatis, secundum illud ad Romanos primo8: « Dicentes, se esse sapientes, stulti facti sunt ». Unde alloquitur Dominus Ieremiae quinto: « Audi, popule stulte, non habens cor, qui habentes oculos non videtis, et aures, et non auditis ». Et quia ipsi videntes noluerunt credere, ideo sunt excaecati; Psalmus: « Obscurentur oculi eorum, ne videant » etc.

Quaestiones.

53. Quaest. I. Sed quaeritur hic primo de hoc quod Dominus quaerit, utrum credat in Filium Dei.

1. Constans est, quod stat ibi pro divina natura; sed post subdit: Vidisti eum; eum est relativum9, ergo refert secundum divinam naturam: ergo caecus vidit divinam naturam.

2. Item, si fides est de his quae non videntur10, quomodo hortatur Dominus, ut credat in eum quem videt?

Respondeo: Dicendum, quod idiomatum est communicatio propter convenientiam in una hypostasi11. Unde sicut dicitur idem mortuus et aeternus, sic idem, in quem credendum, quia aequalis Patri; idem qui loquitur et videtur, sed in forma servi12.

54. Quaest. II. Item quaeritur de hoc quod dicit: In iudicium ego veni in mundum; quia supra tertio13 dicitur: Non misit Deus Filium suum, ut iudicet mundum.

Respondetur, quod venit in iudicium discretionis, sed non condemnationis14.

Aliter tamen potest dici, quod differt dicere veni in iudicium, et ad iudicium: venire ad iudicium p. 382 dicit finalem intentionem ad iudicandum; sic non venit in primo adventu; sed venire in iudicium est ex adventu eius aliquod fieri iudicium in superbos, quia excaecantur ex eius adventu, quamvis ad hoc non veniat1.

55. Quaest. III. Item quaeritur de hoc quod dicit: Ut qui non vident videant, et qui vident caeci fiant. — Videtur ergo, quod a Domino Iesu Christo sit2 excaecatio. Et hoc quidem videtur dici debere per rationem: quia, si excaecatio est poena, et omnis poena iusta est, et quod iustum est bonum est, et quod bonum est a Deo est3: ergo excaecatio est a Deo.

Sed contra: 1. Deus est lux4, sicut et calor: ergo si caloris non est infrigidare, nec lucis est obscurare: ergo nec excaecare.

2. Item, Deus appetit semper, suam imaginem sibi conformari: ergo si excaecatio deformat, Dei non est excaecare.

Respondetur, quod excaecatio potest considerari aut secundum id quod est; et sic privatio est et non habet causam efficientem, sed deficientem. Deus autem nullius est causa deficiens; et sic eius est causa malitia nostra; unde Sapientiae secundo5: Excaecavit eos malitia eorum. Quia tamen excaecatio et induratio poenae sunt, ponunt esse secundum id quod sunt; et poena secundum id quod est, iusta est, et sic, secundum id quod est, potest esse a Deo6.

Amplius videtur dicendum, quod dupliciter est aliqua poena a Deo: uno modo, sicut ab ordinante; et sic peccatum, quod est poena peccati, secundum quod est poena, a Deo est, et sic non est a Deo secundum id quod est7, sed in quantum poena. — Alio modo aliqua poena dicitur esse a Deo secundum id quod est, et hoc vel a Deo infligente; et hoc modo mors et poenae aliae8, per quas contingit mereri. — Alio modo, a Deo aliquid subtrahente nostro merito; et sic fomes a Deo. Cessavit enim Deus dare animae gratiam, per quam regeret carnem, et hoc merito nostro; qua gratia subtracta, caro ad inferius declinavit. — Tertio modo, sicut a non apponente nostris meritis; et sic excaecatio et obduratio. Aliquis enim obduratur in malo, quia a Domino non visitatur, iusto iudicio; aliquis excaecatur, quia interius non illuminatur; ita dicit Augustinus9.

---

p. 380

In the third part is described the spiritual illumination of the blind man.

46. Jesus heard. This is the third part of the chapter, in which, the wonderful illumination of the blind man and the disputing of the Jews having now been described, there is brought in, third, his spiritual illumination. And the Evangelist describes it in this order: for first is noted the kindly calling of the despised blind man himself; second, the inward illumination of him consenting; third is intimated the just blinding of the proud Jews themselves.

(Vers. 35.). First, then, is intimated the kindly calling of the outcast blind man. For the Pharisees cast him out, and the Lord took him up; therefore he says: Jesus heard that they had cast him out; of himself he knew it, but nonetheless it was reported to him. And when Jesus had found him, not by chance, but with an eagerness to take him up; Luke, the fifteenth chapter9: « She lighteth a candle and seeketh diligently, until she find it »; he said to him: Dost thou believe in the Son of God? By asking he rouses and by rousing he calls, that he may take up the outcast, according to that of the Psalm10: « My father and my mother have left me, but the Lord hath taken me up »; Jeremias, the forty-ninth chapter: « Leave thy fatherless children, and I will make thee live ».

47. (Vers. 36.). He answered and said. Here the second is touched on, namely the instruction or inward illumination of him consenting. For the blind man consented to the faith; whence he said: Who is he, Lord, that I may believe in him? As if he should say: I am ready to believe; whence Chrysostom11: « It is the word of one inquiring and desiring »; therefore he is instructed. Therefore:

48. (Vers. 37.). Jesus said12 to him: Thou hast both seen him; and he that talketh with thee, he it is. Thou hast seen, through p. 381 the miraculous working; he talketh with thee, through the wonderful instruction; above, in the eighth chapter1: « The beginning, who also speak unto you ». In like manner the Lord instructed the Samaritan woman, above, in the fourth chapter: « I am he, who am speaking with thee ». And because « with the heart we believe unto justice, but with the mouth confession is made unto salvation », therefore there follows the true confession of the illuminated blind man; and he confessed his faith in word, saying:

49. (Vers. 38.). I believe2, Lord; and by the homage of devotion, whence: And falling down, he adored him, as God, who alone is to be adored with latria; whence the Lord answered the devil in Matthew, the fourth chapter: « The Lord thy God shalt thou adore, and him only shalt thou serve »; Deuteronomy, the sixth chapter: « Thou shalt fear the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve ».

50. (Vers. 39.). And Jesus said to him3. Here the third is touched on, namely the just blinding of the Jews, which the Lord makes manifest to the blind man, for the manifesting of which he also illuminated him bodily. Therefore he says: For judgement I am come into this world; that they who see not, may see; and they who see, may become blind. For judgement, namely of discernment, that they who see, that is, reckon that they see, as the Jews, may become blind. Of this judgement it is said in Romans, the eleventh chapter4: « I would not have you ignorant, brethren, lest you should be wise in your own conceits, that blindness in part has happened in Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles should come in »; and again in Romans, the ninth chapter: « The Gentiles, who followed not after justice, have attained to justice; but Israel, by following after the law of justice, is not come unto the law of justice ». And that that judgement is just is plain from the inquiry of the Pharisees and the response of the Lord, in which is intimated the malice and pertinacity of the Jews; because, although they saw, they would not believe and understand: and therefore by the judgement of God and by their own sin they were blinded5; therefore he says:

51. (Vers. 40.). Some of the Pharisees heard6, who were with him, that is, were there present; and they said: Are we also blind? They were indignant at the word of the Lord, because they believed it had been said on their account, because they reckoned themselves wise: and from this very thing the Lord shows the divine judgement, that they were justly blinded; on account of which:

52. (Vers. 41.). Jesus said to them: If you were blind, you should not have sin; because then the Lord would illuminate you; whence First Corinthians, the third chapter7: « If any man among you seem to be wise in this world, let him become a fool, that he may be wise ». But now you say: We see, and you reckon yourselves wise; your sin remaineth, namely of unbelief, according to that of Romans, the first chapter8: « Saying that they were wise, they became fools ». Whence the Lord addresses them in Jeremias, the fifth chapter: « Hear, O foolish people, and without understanding: who have eyes, and see not: and ears, and hear not ». And because, seeing, they would not believe, therefore they were blinded; the Psalm: « Let their eyes be darkened that they see not » etc.

Questions.

53. Quaest. I. But it is asked here, first, about this, that the Lord asks whether he believes in the Son of God.

1. It is certain that it stands there for the divine nature; but afterwards he adds: Thou hast seen him; him is a relative9, therefore it refers according to the divine nature: therefore the blind man saw the divine nature.

2. Likewise, if faith is of those things which are not seen10, how does the Lord exhort him to believe in him whom he sees?

I respond: It must be said that there is a communication of idioms because of the agreement in one hypostasis11. Whence, just as the same one is said to be dead and eternal, so the same one is he in whom one must believe, because equal to the Father; the same one who speaks and is seen, but in the form of a servant12.

54. Quaest. II. Likewise it is asked about what he says: For judgement I am come into the world; because above, in the third chapter13, it is said: God sent not his Son, to judge the world.

It is responded that he came for the judgement of discernment, but not of condemnation14.

Yet it can be said otherwise, that it differs to say I am come for judgement and to judgement: to come to judgement p. 382 expresses the final intention of judging; so he did not come at the first coming; but to come for judgement is that from his coming some judgement comes about upon the proud, because they are blinded from his coming, although he does not come for this1.

55. Quaest. III. Likewise it is asked about what he says: That they who see not, may see; and they who see, may become blind. — It seems, then, that blinding is2 from the Lord Jesus Christ. And this indeed it seems must be said by reason: because, if blinding is a punishment, and every punishment is just, and what is just is good, and what is good is from God3: therefore blinding is from God.

On the contrary: 1. God is light4, as also heat: therefore if it is not of heat to chill, neither is it of light to darken: therefore neither to blind.

2. Likewise, God always desires his image to be conformed to himself: therefore if blinding deforms, it is not God's to blind.

It is responded that blinding can be considered either according to that which it is; and so it is a privation and has not an efficient cause, but a deficient one. But God is the deficient cause of nothing; and so its cause is our malice; whence Wisdom, the second chapter5: Their malice blinded them. Yet because blinding and induration are punishments, they posit being according to that which they are; and a punishment, according to that which it is, is just, and so, according to that which it is, it can be from God6.

It seems, further, that it must be said that a punishment is from God in two ways: in one way, as from one ordaining; and so sin, which is the punishment of sin, according as it is a punishment, is from God, and so it is not from God according to that which it is7, but inasmuch as it is a punishment. — In another way some punishment is said to be from God according to that which it is, and this either from God inflicting; and in this way death and the other punishments8, through which it befalls us to merit. — In another way, from God withdrawing something by our desert; and so the tinder is from God. For God ceased to give the soul the grace by which it might rule the flesh, and this by our desert; which grace being withdrawn, the flesh declined to what is lower. — In the third way, as from one not adding to our merits; and so blinding and obduration. For someone is obdurate in evil because he is not visited by the Lord, by just judgement; someone is blinded because he is not illuminated within; so says Augustine9.

---

Apparatus Criticus
  1. 9
    Vers. 8.
    Verse 8.
  2. 10
    Psalm. 26, 10. — Sequitur Ier. 49, 11.
    Psalm 26:10. — There follows Jer. 49:11.
  3. 11
    In Ioan. homil. 59. (alias 58.) n. 1: Optantis ac vehementer desiderantis verbum. — Pro inquirentis, quod etiam card. Hugo et S. Thomas (in Catena aurea, in hunc locum) exhibent, plures codd. cum Gorrano requirentis. Textus originalis: Ποθούσης καὶ σφόδρα ἐπιζητούσης ψυχῆς τὸ ῥῆμα.
    On John, homily 59 (otherwise 58), n. 1: The word of one wishing and vehemently desiring. — For inquirentis ("of one inquiring"), which Cardinal Hugh and St. Thomas (in the Catena aurea, on this place) also give, several codices with Gorran have requirentis ("of one seeking"). The original text: Ποθούσης καὶ σφόδρα ἐπιζητούσης ψυχῆς τὸ ῥῆμα ("the word of a soul longing and earnestly seeking").
  4. 12
    Vulgata Et dixit.
    The Vulgate has Et dixit ("And … said").
  5. 1
    Vers. 25. — Duo seqq. loci sunt Ioan. 4, 26. et Rom. 10, 10.
    Verse 25. — The two following places are John 4:26 and Rom. 10:10.
  6. 2
    Vulgata At ille ait: Credo. — Sequuntur Matth. 4, 10. et Deut. 6, 13. — De latria cfr. III. Sent. d. 9. per totam.
    The Vulgate has At ille ait: Credo ("And he said: I believe"). — There follow Matt. 4:10 and Deut. 6:13. — On latria cf. III Sent. d. 9 throughout.
  7. 3
    Vulgata omittit ei.
    The Vulgate omits ei ("to him").
  8. 4
    Vers. 25. Etiam hic, sicut supra pag. 290, nota 5, codd. nostri intravit pro contigit. — Sequitur Rom. 9, 30. seq. — August., in Ioan. Evang. tr. 44. n. 17: Quid est: qui vident, caeci fiant? Qui se putant videre et medicum non quaerunt in sua caecitate permaneant. Ergo istam discretionem vocavit iudicium, cum ait: In iudicium veni in hunc mundum, quo discernit causam credentium et confitentium a superbis se videre putantibus, et ideo gravius excaecatis etc.
    Verse 25. Here too, as above, p. 290, note 5, our codices have intravit ("has entered") for contigit ("has happened"). — There follows Rom. 9:30 f. — Augustine, On the Gospel of John, tr. 44, n. 17: What is: they who see may become blind? Let those who think they see and do not seek the physician remain in their blindness. Therefore he called this discernment judgement, when he says: For judgement I am come into this world, by which he discerns the cause of those believing and confessing from the proud who think they see, and are therefore the more gravely blinded etc.
  9. 5
    Cfr. infra n. 54. et 55. — Superius voci iudicio ed. praefigit iusto.
    Cf. below, n. 54 and 55. — Above, to the word iudicio ("by the judgement") the edition prefixes iusto ("just").
  10. 6
    Vulgata Et audierunt, quae etiam inferius post dixerunt addit ei.
    The Vulgate has Et audierunt ("And … heard"), which also below adds ei ("to him") after dixerunt ("they said").
  11. 7
    Vers. 18. — Inferius pro Nunc autem Vulgata Nunc vero.
    Verse 18. — Below, for Nunc autem ("But now") the Vulgate has Nunc vero ("But now").
  12. 8
    Vers. 22. — Duo seqq. loci sunt Ier. 5, 21. et Ps. 68, 24. — Subinde verbo alloquitur ed. praefigit tales.
    Verse 22. — The two following places are Jer. 5:21 and Ps. 68:24. — Next, to the word alloquitur ("addresses") the edition prefixes tales ("such").
  13. 9
    Petr. Hispan., Summul. tr. de Suppositione etc.: Aliud est relativum, quod est ante latae rei recordativum; quia, ut vult Priscianus in maiore volumine [XII. Grammat. c. 4.], « relatio est ante latae rei recordatio » [sive ut Priscianus habet: repraesentatio]. — Superius pro stat ibi ed. Filius Dei stat. Subinde exhibemus lectionem plurimorum codd. ergo refert [supple: Filium Dei] secundum divinam naturam, a qua lectione discedunt Gorranus et ed. tantum in eo, quod omittant secundum; C N ergo refert ad divinam.
    Peter of Spain, Summulae, tract on Supposition etc.: Another is the relative, which is recollective of a thing brought forward before; because, as Priscian holds in the greater volume [XII Grammar, c. 4], « relation is the recollection of a thing brought forward before » [or as Priscian has it: representation]. — Above, for stat ibi ("it stands there") the edition has Filius Dei stat ("Son of God stands"). Next we give the reading of most codices, ergo refert [supply: the Son of God] secundum divinam naturam ("therefore it refers according to the divine nature"), from which reading Gorran and the edition depart only in omitting secundum ("according to"); C N have ergo refert ad divinam ("therefore it refers to the divine").
  14. 10
    Vide supra pag. 329, notam 3.
    See above, p. 329, note 3.
  15. 11
    Cfr. tom. III. pag. 14, nota 3. verba Damasceni.
    Cf. tome III, p. 14, note 3, the words of Damascene.
  16. 12
    Respicitur Phil. 2, 6. seq.
    Phil. 2:6 f. is in view.
  17. 13
    Vers. 17.
    Verse 17.
  18. 14
    Cfr. supra n. 50; c. 3. n. 30-37. et c. 5. n. 55. seqq.
    Cf. above, n. 50; c. 3, n. 30–37; and c. 5, n. 55 ff.
  19. 1
    Chrysost., in Ioan. homil. 56. (alias 55.) n. 1: Quidam vero dicunt, hanc particulam [ut in 9, 3: Ut manifestentur opera Dei] non esse causalem, sed ex eventu dici, ut quando dicit [Ioan. 9, 39.]: In iudicium veni in hunc mundum, ut non videntes videant, et qui vident caeci fiant. Non enim venit, ut videntes caeci fierent. Et rursum Paulus [Rom. 1, 19.]: Nam quod notum est Dei manifestum est in illis, ut sint inexcusabiles; etsi non ideo manifestaverit, ut excusatione privarentur, sed ut illam haberent etc.
    Chrysostom, On John, homily 56 (otherwise 55), n. 1: But some say that this particle [ut ("that") in 9:3: That the works of God should be made manifest] is not causal, but is said of the outcome, as when he says [John 9:39]: For judgement I am come into this world, that they who see not may see, and they who see may become blind. For he did not come in order that those seeing should become blind. And again Paul [Rom. 1:19]: For that which is known of God is manifest in them, that they may be inexcusable; although he did not manifest it in order that they should be deprived of excuse, but that they should have it etc.
  20. 2
    Ed. fit, C fiat.
    The edition has fit ("comes about"), C fiat ("should come about").
  21. 3
    Cfr. supra pag. 116, nota 12. et pag. 375, nota 7.
    Cf. above, p. 116, note 12, and p. 375, note 7.
  22. 4
    Epist. I. Ioan. 1, 5. Cfr. supra pag. 368, nota 7. verba Dionysii.
    I John 1:5. Cf. above, p. 368, note 7, the words of Dionysius.
  23. 5
    Vers. 21. — August., XII. de Civ. Dei, c. 7: « Nemo igitur quaerat efficientem causam malae voluntatis; non enim est efficiens, sed deficiens, quia nec illa affectio est, sed defectio ». Ibid. c. 8: Hoc scio, naturam Dei nunquam, nusquam, nulla ex parte posse deficere, et ea posse deficere, quae ex nihilo facta sunt.
    Verse 21. — Augustine, City of God XII, c. 7: « Let no one therefore seek an efficient cause of the evil will; for it is not efficient, but deficient, because that is not an affection either, but a defection ». Ibid., c. 8: This I know, that the nature of God can never, nowhere, in no part fail, and that those things can fail which were made from nothing.
  24. 6
    Fide D supplevimus potest esse a Deo. Ed., variata interpunctione, legit: iusta est. Secundum id quod est, amplius videtur dicendum etc. [in propositione seq.]. Superius, omisso cum aliis codd. sunt, pro ponunt C E N ponuntur, B possunt.
    On the faith of D we have supplied potest esse a Deo ("it can be from God"). The edition, with the punctuation altered, reads: iusta est. Secundum id quod est, amplius videtur dicendum ("is just. According to that which it is, it seems further that it must be said") etc. [in the following proposition]. Above, sunt ("are") being omitted with other codices, for ponunt ("they posit") C E N have ponuntur ("they are posited"), B possunt ("they can").
  25. 7
    Ed., verbis transpositis, et secundum quod est peccatum, sic non est a Deo [Gorranus: et secundum quod est peccatum, sic non est a Deo, secundum illud quod est].
    The edition, with the words transposed, has et secundum quod est peccatum, sic non est a Deo ("and according as it is sin, so it is not from God") [Gorran: and according as it is sin, so it is not from God, according to that which it is].
  26. 8
    Ed. cum Gorrano supplet sunt a Deo.
    The edition with Gorran supplies sunt a Deo ("are from God").
  27. 9
    Vide supra pag. 211, notam 4. Cfr. etiam I. Sent. d. 40. a. 4. q. 1. seq. et II. Sent. d. 36. per totam, praecipue a. 1. q. 1. et a. 3. q. 2, ubi loci diversi August. allegati sunt. In libro de Praedest. et gratia (inter opera August.) c. 4, praemisso, quod Deus in homine ipsam obdurationem sive duritiam cordis non operatur, sed ab ipso iuste meritoque reddi fateri debeamus, dicitur: « Indurare enim Deus dicitur eum quem mollire noluerit; sic etiam excaecare dicendus est eum quem illuminare noluerit; sic etiam repellere eum quem vocare noluerit ».
    See above, p. 211, note 4. Cf. also I Sent. d. 40, a. 4, q. 1 f., and II Sent. d. 36 throughout, especially a. 1, q. 1 and a. 3, q. 2, where various places of Augustine are adduced. In the book On Predestination and Grace (among the works of Augustine), c. 4, having set down first that God does not work obduration itself, or hardness of heart, in man, but that we must confess it is rendered by him justly and deservedly, it is said: « For God is said to harden him whom he has not willed to soften; so also he is to be said to blind him whom he has not willed to illuminate; so also to repel him whom he has not willed to call ».
Cite this

St. Bonaventure, Commentarius in Evangelium S. Ioannis, Cap. 9, Vers. 35-41, in Opera Omnia (Quaracchi, 1893), tom. VI, pp. 380–382.

English translation: Wroot Press, Bonaventure Opera Omnia Translation Project, bonaventure.wrootpress.com/ioannem/c9-v35-41. Licensed CC BY-NC 4.0.

Authorities cited here

Augustine of Hippo, De civitate Dei, In Ioannis Evangelium tractatus · John Chrysostom, Homiliae in Ioannem (2) · Peter of Spain, Summulae logicales · Priscian, Institutiones grammaticae · Thomas Aquinas, Catena aurea